quote: (post)

Originally posted by Inhuman
Spite

quote: (post)

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
At what point in that story arc would Superman fall?

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
If written by Starling, Superman clears it. Starling respects Superman a lot

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Well if We are using a starling arc it will be fair to use a starling depiction of Superman, if that is the case he will clear it.

If you use Byrne Superman then no

quote: (post)

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Even if Starling writes it, how does he beat Maker?

Punching and blasting it hard wont be enough...

And considering what Maker did to Thanos with its alpha attack (one shot KO'ing Thanos when even a High End Skyfather like Odin failed to KO Thanos with multiple attacks), does Superman even survive that?

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Starling put Superman in the middle of a cosmic battle with out getting killed, he got Ko though.

But under starling survived the fusion of new genesis and apokolips two massive planets that collided so hard that they fused together.

Under atarling when Galactus did something similar in a lesser scale he got in pretty bad shape.

Also superman was able with physical force to break darkseids body when the source power was unable to even scratch him

That is why I am telling you that Starling respects Superman a lot

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Starling put Superman in the middle of a cosmic battle with out getting killed, he got Ko though.

But under starling survived the fusion of new genesis and apokolips two massive planets that collided so hard that they fused together.

Under atarling when Galactus did something similar in a lesser scale he got in pretty bad shape.

Also superman was able with physical force to break darkseids body when the source power was unable to even scratch him

That is why I am telling you that Starling respects Superman a lot

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Insane Titan
this is a typical twist of context from a superman fan regarding the two planets crashing together on Galactus. The planets Galactus encountered had a sizeable nuclear Arsenal at the point of impact, plus Galactus had just drained himself on Thanos shields and fighting the hunger.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Insane Titan
this is a typical twist of context from a superman fan regarding the two planets crashing together on Galactus. The planets Galactus encountered had a sizeable nuclear Arsenal at the point of impact, plus Galactus had just drained himself on Thanos shields and fighting the hunger.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Superman's feat was on a bigger scale, with a LOT more force involved

quote: (post)

Originally posted by basilisk
That was a pretty dumb plan though. I mean adding a nuclear arsenal to two full-size planets crashing together is like the pilot of the Enola Gay tossing some firecrackers out the window over Hiroshima to "crank up the damage". It's a waste of time considering the difference in orders of magnitude between the two explosions. You could collect and detonate every nuke that ever existed together x 1000 and it won't really damage the structure of the planet.

In fact it might have actually helped Galactus survive, because I'm pretty sure his cosmic power allows him to absorb energy from the radiation released from the nukes and replenish his strength to some extent, while I don't think he just straight absorbs kinetic energy.

As far as the Maker goes, I just don't see current Superman cutting it. Preboot Superman I can see the writers could pull off giving Supes the win based on some of his old feats.