Originally posted by Quiero Mota
But does his list really stray from your opinions?Do do think God isn't real, you do think prayer is a waste of time, and theist are responsible for a lot of bad things, don't you? And I know you think all that, so you really don't have an argument.
Not really surprised you took the opportunity to pile on me. You'd think that eventually you might realize that my comments generally work toward decreasing the amount of negativity on the forums, and then decide to refrain from adding to it yourself. But if you feel the need to drag your own vendetta against me into a matter that should've be laid to rest by now (by Sym and myself, no one else) then I'm more than happy to oblige you.
Anyway, you're missing the point entirely. Sym's comment was intended as a slight toward the entire forum. He marginalized what he feels are recurring arguments in the forum, and turned it into a form of mockery. I pointed out that legitimate, respectful discussion occurs regularly, and to generalize it into a few trite points and act like that's all there is, is both non-constructive for discussion and insulting to regular members.
So it's not the points themselves that I was against, which is the point that you seem to have missed entirely. It's the intent with which he uttered them, and the sarcastic, condescending tone.
Also, just to clarify (not that it normally matters with you, since you've ignored me in the past in order to paint me as some sort of godless stereotype) I don't "think theists are responsible for a lot of bad things." Of course they are. Atheists are responsible for a lot of bad things too. And both sides are responsible for a lot of good things as well. It's not religion that I'm against, it's abuse of beliefs to do things that cause harm and suffering to others. I've also never said prayer is a waste of time. The fact that a divine creator may not be there to answer them doesn't mean there isn't thereputic and/or emotional value in putting one's mind in a prayerful state. Prayer can and does help people quite a bit, even though I think its their own mental devices creating the healing rather than a god. There's also a few others I don't agree with, but the comments weren't directed specifically at me, but in general, so it's a moot point.
So pretty please, hate me if you must, but don't put words in my mouth and pretend that you aren't lying while you try to slander me.