Ulic kicks ass but I don't know much about the Exile. To make your scenario sound cooler say there in the prescence of a ysalamari. They disperse the force and allow it to not be used around them.
__________________ I have to get myself organizized.
At the start of Kotor II what is the exile? A nothing a nobody a normal human being, well a bit more powerful then that, but nothing special. Ulic was great even without the force
When he was growing up, he was considered a progidy, one of the best jedi even. He tamed the Onderon system when he was still an apprentice, killing a sith and numerous other people. He was urged to leave, but he decided to stay and fight the dark side from within, then he fell to the dark side.
He was the apprentice to Exar Kun, and nearly fought him to a standstill before Exar was proclaimed the dark lord.
He defeated Mandalore in single combat and ruled the Mandalorians. He led an assualt on Courscant and was betrayed and captured. Once he was freed by Exar, he killed the person who betrayed him by sending her to a planet and blowing up its sun, killing her.
Ulic also killed his own brother in combat and then when he realized what he did, he came back to the light and had his connection to the force stripped away fom him. After this he went into Exile for 20 years, not practising with a lightsaber or using the force (since it was taken from him).
Now I'll admit, this makes Ulic sound weak, but this is where it gets interesting. After being in exile for 20 years, not using the force or a lightsaber, Ulic was tracked down by the daughter of Nomi Sunrider because she wanted to be trained. I find this interesting, she was the daughter of the most powerful jedi at the time, yet she wanted to be trained by Ulic, knowing even in his weakened state, he was still stronger than Nomi was. Ulic agreed and started to train her. After a couple of months, they were tracked down again, this time by Nomi and another jedi knight, a cathar. A duel erupted between Ulic and the cathar jedi. The cathar jedi had been a jedi knight for several years and even fought against Ulic and Exar in the sith wars and was hailed a hero. She had also been using the force and training for the 20 years Ulic was in exile. Yet, Ulic was able to defeat a fully trained jedi master, who was using the force and was nearly on the dark side. He could not use the force, and had not used a lightsaber in 20 years. He also could not use the force to sense her movements and guide his lightsaber (which is the main reason jedi are so skilled with a blade), yet he was able to defeat her. Then when he turned to embrace Nomi (they used to be lovers), he was shot in the back. Even though he lost his connection to the force, his body still dissolved and he became one with the force.
__________________ >>Antediluvian<< Stop the flood!
he was killed by a pilot shooting him in the back, Ulic had just defeated a jedi knight (without the force), and had his back turned, then he was shot, since he couldn't sense it coming, he died.
And I say Ulic would win, the Exile when banished was weak, he certainly couldn't kill off a powerful jedi knight (it was a cathar, so think Juhani at the end of KotOR, but around half again as strong), by himself when the jedi can use the force and he couldn't
Plus, Ulic trained under Exar and knew more about the jedi and sith than the exile will ever learn
__________________ >>Antediluvian<< Stop the flood!