Darth caedus vs darth sidious
Darth caedus died aged 32 but yet still managed to almost fight luke go a standstill and all of his other amazing feats
So if caedus was allowed to live for another 10 or so years could he have surpassed sidious?
Think about it tho
Caedus was only 32 roughly when he faced luke
Reborn palpatine faced a weaker luke skywalker than caedus faced and got owned
While caedus faced a more powerful like and not only survived but injured luke and moved fast enough to almost throw him off guard
Not saying caedus is stronger than sidious but given another 15 years of training he would be most likely. Idk just my opinion
Well that obviously changed by the time they fought properly, caedus must have grown stronger
Because if luke could have done that to caedus when they fought, he would. But he instead almost died to caedus all whilst caedus was only 32
Also I don't agree with his analysis of the fight with luke, saying that luke had an injury before the fight. Yes a scar, but that only affected luke because caedus exploited it. There are more flaws in his argument imo but won't go into it
Last edited by hutchy1345 on Jan 23rd, 2016 at 11:09 PM
Caedus may have a decent showing against Luke, but that doesn't put him on Luke's or Sidious' level. I've examined that fight and remember lots of details that suggested it wasn't anywhere near a generic all out arena type clash between two opponents as lots of factors have to be taken into account that are unique to that confrontation.
In other words, Sidious doesn't need the storms to win but it will definitely guarantee him the victory.
Caedus may have a decent showing against Luke, but that doesn't put him on Luke's or Sidious' level. I've examined that fight and remember lots of details that suggested it wasn't anywhere near a generic all out arena type clash between two opponents as lots of factors have to be taken into account that are unique to that confrontation.
Yes I know, Sidious would definitely defeat caedus, but he has at least double the years of training/knowledge. Caedus was 32 when he died, if he had lived another 10-15 years and fought sidious he probably would have won, that's what this thread is about.
I understand what this thread is about. Luke's more prodigious than Jacen. I'm confident that anything less than peak Luke won't be enough to take down Sidious, and a 45 year old Caedus should logically be less than peak Luke.