quote: (post)

Originally posted by The Ellimist
It depends on Anakin's mental state.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Team 1.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Team 1.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by JKBart
Vader and Anakin are meaningless here - they wouldn't be able to contribute anything in a battle between "Revans", so I'll focus on that, especially since it's pretty complicated.

Full power SOR is pretty much superior to Reborn Revan at least if you view their showings. Revan's most insane showing is the fight he gives to the strike team in SOR, especially since he's extremely hindered. One can argue though, that SOR Revan has no right to be superior to Reborn Revan. SoR Revan's power is essentially cut in half in the fight that goes there, he's mentally unstable, and there's not much of a reason to believe he truly improved. He spent his time and huge development between Jedi times and post-KotOR times, had incredible amount of war experience and mental trials and pretty much not much he could go through any longer, then he also trained his willpower for 300 years, and spent rest of his life mentally damaged.

Going by that line of logic, Reborn Revan really has to be superior to SoR Revan, but then again, it's SoR where he shows his best showing. If we truly consider that:
- SoR Revan is hugely amped by Yavin IV,
- he however has half his power hindered,
- he is mentally imbalanced,
- either out of his prime, or, at best, in his past prime still,
then we have to agree that prime Reborn Revan would be pretty much superior to Palpatine or Luke, and inferior to Valkorion only by a small notch.

That's what makes the rating damn hard. SoR Revan can't be his prime going by all the facts about Revan as noted, but if we put Reborn Revan as properly logically ahead of SoR Revan, we have Revan as someone far above Yoda, kek.