#16
BALLER STATUS IV LIFE
Gender: Male Location: The 139.
DC vs. Marvel (book for book, just how you like it)
who continue to provide the most quality stories between the big two... let's find out shall we?
first ill do my opinion,and i hope you add-on
ill pair em like this:
DCU = MU
Vertigo = MAX
Wildstorm = Marvel Knights
-let's leave out the ultimate line first because dc's all star imprint is just starting
****************************
DCU vs. MU
FLAGSHIP TITLE-
SUPERMAN/BATMAN (DC) vs. NEW AVENGERS (Marvel)
winner- new avengers
MAIN TEAM BOOK-
JLA (DC) vs. ASTONISHING X-MEN (Marvel)
winner- AXM
MAIN HERO BOOK-
BATMAN (DC) vs. AMAZING SPIDER-MAN (Marvel)
winner- Batman
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
SEVEN SOLDIERS (DC) vs. RUNAWAYS (Marvel)
winner- runaways
****************************
Vertigo vs. MAX
FLAGSHIP TITLE
SWAMP THING (DC) vs. SUPREME POWER (Marvel)
winner- swamp thing
MAIN HERO BOOK
HELLBLAZER (DC) vs. PUNISHER (Marvel)
winner- Hellblazer
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
FABLES winner by default
****************************
Wildstorm vs. Marvel Knights
FLAGSHIP TITLE-
THE AUTHORITY (DC) vs. SPIDER-MAN (Marvel)
winner- the authority
MAIN HERO BOOK-
MAJESTIC (DC) vs. WOLVERINE (Marvel)
winner- wolverine
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
EX MACHINA (DC) vs. DAREDEVIL (Marvel)
winner- ex machina
*****************************
so there goes my list, i hope i didnt piss off a lotta people
ill try to explain my choices later
__________________
DarkCrawler >>> Your Favorite Sig-Maker
Sep 7th, 2005 02:26 PM
willRules
4 8 15 16 23 42
Gender: Male Location: LOST
I agree with all of those except for Batman vs amazing spidey and authority vs spider-man
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 03:59 PM
#16
BALLER STATUS IV LIFE
Gender: Male Location: The 139.
^with batman vs amazing spidey id actually confess that that is pretty close... perhaps even going into spidey's favor
but
with the authority vs. mk spiderman.... authority outclasses mk spidey way too much.
__________________
DarkCrawler >>> Your Favorite Sig-Maker
Sep 7th, 2005 04:18 PM
willRules
4 8 15 16 23 42
Gender: Male Location: LOST
ok its your opinion.
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 04:35 PM
HaSon
Senior Member
Gender: Male Location: Flying the fanboy flag
I like Superman/Batman a hell of alot more than New Avengers and also JLA more than X-Men.
On the other hand, I'd take Supreme Power anyday over Swamp Thing.
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 06:44 PM
Draco69
Snarky Slytherin
Gender: Male Location: United States
Superman/Batman is really lame in my opinion. Very nonsensical.
New Avengers is pretty entertaining and funny.
JLA has lost all validity to me ever since Morrison left. Kelly was a nice stand in though. Any other fill in was a mere shadow to the Morrison age.
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 07:36 PM
Adam Warlock
Adam is with Team Magik
Gender: Unspecified Location: Northern Nevada
Swamp Thing beating out Supreme Power.... Not in my book. Swamp Thing is one of the few DC comics I actually collect, but Supreme Power kicks ass.
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 08:01 PM
HigH ScholaR
Senior Member
Gender: Male Location:
^ second that
Suprem power in my opion has to be one of the best comic that have graced my hard earned money to have come so far.
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 08:21 PM
willRules
4 8 15 16 23 42
Gender: Male Location: LOST
Im really enjoying Amazing Spider-man at the moment and New Avengers....these two I would choose over any others at the moment..........
__________________
Sep 7th, 2005 08:29 PM
#16
BALLER STATUS IV LIFE
Gender: Male Location: The 139.
wow. im suprised yall love supreme power that much.
i agree supreme power is the truth... that's the real deal from marvel... but i never thought a lot of people read it.
as for swamp thing winning, i said it because of the longevity, the consistency of quality and the impact it made with the vertio print.
c'mon guys make up your own list!
__________________
DarkCrawler >>> Your Favorite Sig-Maker
Sep 8th, 2005 03:01 PM
eleveninches
God of my own world
Gender: Male Location: Here
Re: DC vs. Marvel (book for book, just how you like it)
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
who continue to provide the most quality stories between the big two... let's find out shall we?
first ill do my opinion,and i hope you add-on
ill pair em like this:
DCU = MU
Vertigo = MAX
Wildstorm = Marvel Knights
-let's leave out the ultimate line first because dc's all star imprint is just starting
****************************
[b]DCU vs. MU
FLAGSHIP TITLE-
SUPERMAN/BATMAN (DC) vs. NEW AVENGERS (Marvel)
winner- new avengers
I DISAGREE
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
MAIN TEAM BOOK-
JLA (DC) vs. ASTONISHING X-MEN (Marvel)
winner- AXM
I DISAGREE
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
[B]
MAIN HERO BOOK-
BATMAN (DC) vs. AMAZING SPIDER-MAN (Marvel)
winner- Batman
I AGREE (BTW, spiderman isnt a hero, he's evil)
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
[B]
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
SEVEN SOLDIERS (DC) vs. RUNAWAYS (Marvel)
winner- runaways
****************************
[b]Vertigo vs. MAX
FLAGSHIP TITLE
SWAMP THING (DC) vs. SUPREME POWER (Marvel)
winner- swamp thing
I DISAGREE (i wold have put hellblazer or lucifer as vertigo's flagship title, bith of which are better than supreme power)
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
MAIN HERO BOOK
HELLBLAZER (DC) vs. PUNISHER (Marvel)
winner- Hellblazer
AGREED (although it's debatable as to whether or not JC is a hero)
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
[B]
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
FABLES winner by default
****************************
[b]Wildstorm vs. Marvel Knights
FLAGSHIP TITLE-
THE AUTHORITY (DC) vs. SPIDER-MAN (Marvel)
winner- the authority
I AGREE
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
MAIN HERO BOOK-
MAJESTIC (DC) vs. WOLVERINE (Marvel)
winner- wolverine
Unsure. Might give this one to wolverine
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Pointinel
[B]
CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED BOOK-
EX MACHINA (DC) vs. DAREDEVIL (Marvel)
winner- ex machina
AGREED
Sep 8th, 2005 04:21 PM
eleveninches
God of my own world
Gender: Male Location: Here
I like Superman/batman WAY more than new avengers. I started to like the original avengers, but the new avengers does nothing for me.
I also like JLA a lot more than X-men (which is odd, as for the first year that i collected comics, i bought nothing except xmen comics)
Sep 8th, 2005 04:24 PM
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
Text-only version