Not so long ago it was quite common for restaurants, shops, hotels and other commercial outlets to refuse service to people because of skin colour. Such a thing is now outlawed under anti-racism laws, however, does this not impinge on the rights of other citizens to serve who they want and employ who they want?
Is it wrong for the owner of a hotel to refuse to give a room to a man because he is black and is it wrong for a shop manager to refuse to employ hispanics?
Also, while this is the Private Sector what about the Public Sector?
Should Local Authorities be able to establish schools for people of different ethnicities and choose who can work in what sort of Public-Owned enterprises?
Gender: Unspecified Location: With Cinderella and the 9 Dwarves
I'd differentiate between "is it wrong" and "should the government ban it". To my personal morals, it is very wrong to deny a black man anything solely due to his race, but, I do not believe that the government should that possibility away, as I also think that it is more wrong of the government to infringe on a person's private decision as to their own believes as well to services their company provide.
On the other hand I understand that such a law, likely furthered the civil rights movement in the earlier days, which is certainly desirable, I just would, probably, not want it at the cost of self-expression, etc.
As for the public sector, decisions based on anything which has nothing to do with the person's own behaviour and/or skill (basically, everything that doesn't judge a person as an individual) should be outright banned.
No, in a liberal democracy private and public facilities and businesses should not have a right to discriminate. furthermore, in a true liberal democracy in order to protect citizen from the tyranny of majorities, it should be illegal for the rights of minorities to be taken away by a popular vote.
__________________ Land of the free, home of the brave...
Do you think we will ever be saved?
In this land of dreams find myself sober...
Wonder when will it'll all be over...
Living in a void when the void grows colder...
Wonder when it'll all be over?
Will you be laughing when it's over?
Well, seeing as Catholicism is a worldwide religion, in many countries, and also seing as most countries have secular governments, I dont see how that could ever happen.
Gender: Unspecified Location: With Cinderella and the 9 Dwarves
Most people are also not smart enough to lead.
Either way, it's a very valid decision for an employer. He should certainly be able to decide who he gives money to in exchange for services. Just as the person should be able to decide who he gives services for, in exchange for money.
Gender: Male Location: Welfare Kingdom of California
Re: Rights of the Employer and Racism
Is it wrong? yes.
Is it legal? depends..business have what they call:
"We reserve the right to refuse service"
Meaning, that they can deny you a sale. But is not as easy as that...the business must have some reason why they deny the service. For example (as a business owner) let's say your regular customers feel affected by a certain individual in your store and ask you to not sell anything to that individual. You have a valid reason.
Did you ever saw the movie "Do the Right Thing"? The scene in which the guy walks in blasting music with his boom box inside a pizza parlor is a clear example of refusing service to certain individuals...even if they're different color.
there are obviously examples where some sort of discrimination is neccessary...for example it would hardly be fitting to have a male as a counselor for female rape victims
i don't agree with the idea of the met police actively discriminating against white applicants because they want more ethnic officers for predominantly ethnic areas of London...
as for discrimination with regards to services...i'm sure alot of small businesses probably do do it...albeit by making up a "legitimate" excuse that's actually just a lie because they don't want to serve someone due to prejudice...some still do it blatently though...i remember the case of a man who ran a small hotel in the highlands who said he wouldn't allow 2 gay men to stay in his hotel.
KMC Community Forums
Dec 1st, 2008 03:17 AM
