who is your fave X - lady between the two ?

i'm going with jean grey

Obviously Rogue, I dont really like jean that much, never have. (storms dtill my fav tho)🙂

rogue all the way! jean is too "miss perfect" and blah blah blah...

I know what you mean ... Rogue is like a little outlaw ;

JEAN!!!

Rogue in all her roles.Jean is boring unless she's letting loose with her powers (sorry!but so is Storm in my opinion.)

Rogue from the Cartoon and Comics, neither from the movie

A good point. Can you comment a little 🙂?

Lisa I agree about the Storm and Jean being boring. I like storm but her personality is kinda boring, shes cool in the movies.Rogue and Jean, no offence to ne one, but they suck in the movies. Rogue is so naive and Jean is a bi*ch but i personally think shes always that way even in comics, i think they did a horrible job portraying Rogue tho shes so cool in the comics.

Thank you for the comments. So ... I like Storm very much because of her story, a very agitated one indeed, and because some moments of real adventure in the cartoons. Halle makes a great Storm ... About the Rogue in the movies, she is kinda too childish

I agree Halle makes a perfect storm, she brings some personallity to her character. I think they could have chosen a better actress for Rogue however

True. Nicole Kidman 😄

As Rogue? no i think shes to old for the part

Maybe, I was just opinioning. There could be a better choice than Paquin though 🙂

Yeah Anna doesnt fit as Rogue

first when i became a fan i like jean in the movie but rogue in cartoon rogue ROCKS!. 💃

I think Anna Paquin is perfect has Rogue. You guys must see that she is younger then the Rogue you know.The 1st movie is her story from the beginnig. But she is building up. I'm sure in the 3rd she'll be more daring (sp).

No I just dont like anna as rogue even if rogue was ment to be younger anna just doesnt seem fit for the part

She is far away from the cartoons lady anyhow

I defintely go with rouge. she is hot!!!! 💃 😮‍💨 💃 😮‍💨 💃 😂 😆