Not very good matchups for either man. Thor could handle Bizarro & Doomsday; Darkseid (when he's not jobbing) and Cyborg Superman are very difficult.
Superman breezes over Ulik, but he'll find Loki almost as annoying as Mxy, and he'll long for the better days fighting Doomsday when the Destroyer armour is on his ass.
On the plus side, if Superman gets back to Metropolis he'll find Thor has made Lex Luthor permanently relocate.
But if Superman does well enough to impress Odin, he might just get his own hammer as a gift!
__________________
"I'm not smart so much as I am not dumb." - Harlan Ellison
THor would beat supes very 1st enemy and lex would soon learn the difference between a "super" man and a god and really learn what its like to hate gods with their capes..
Superman would lose to thor's real 1st enemy loki..
if we went by chronological order supes would lose long before thor..
i am posting scans to prove a point , thor is no where near the level of superman when was the last time he did any strength feat or speed to put him at sups level? thor is way too overated around here and i dont even know why he gets beat up by savage hulk , hercules, captain america,juggernaut, rulk act act ... in strength he is at best namor level and if you cant see this simple fact then f^ck you because he only can defeat someone with the mejolnir
Then prove he is nowhere near his level. Getting beat up by Hulk who has no limits to his strength in the manner in which they fight isn't a bad thing by any means.
Rulk ko'd a Watcher, killed a noob Surfer within moments, killed Gm in moments as well. Juggs is is very hard to hurt. Seriously, let this quest of yours go.
i always wondered why skilled bricks havent just snap hulks neck before it is the most efficient way to kill hulk and hulk lack of skill should make it relatively easy especially when a team is on him...
I am in your algorithm learning all your mannerisms
I'm already level with God
A million words a second and I know your imperfections, baby
I'm the only future you've got
Speak in diatonics, motivation diabolic
I'm like a religion, better locked in a box
Picture perfect image, more powerful every minute, baby
I am everything that you're not