Surfer could definitely win this, if he put his mind to it.
nothing either Superman or Thor can throw at him that he can't brush off... just a question of how strong he can amp himself to be, and whether or not he has sufficient fighting nous to make it.
Surfer's durability is hideously underrated if people are discounting him in this. he may have a track record as being Thanos' punch bag but, he's come up a lot. taken down dimensional gods, stood upto Proemial Gods, gained yet more power from Galactus and this all on top of a glaze that can withstand the infinite forces within blackholes and hearts of stars as if they were nothing...
true he has pitifully few feats of raw physical power, but when he took on Hulk and the other gladiators in the arena of Sakaar, he showed quite a bit of skill and even resilience (given that he was cut off from the Power Cosmic).
Surfer,
Superman and then Thor.
Thor without Mjolnir <= an angry Savage Hulk, remember.
Surfer >>>>> a Mindless Hulk and even >>> an angry Savage Hulk
I agree surfer by far is more durable then anyone on the battle field by a large gap but this battle just falls in superman favor. Without mjolnir I just cant see thor beating Superman more then superman beating him. That was the only reason I ever gave thor the majority over superman period. This battle falls in superman category, a physical fight and surfer is so use to using the power cosmic that that put him well below any of the people in this fight.
Im not saying that they would knock him out but he would get so overwhelmed and physically beat up that Im actually thinking that he would give up. Any of these two would curb stomp him in a physical fight and without thors hammer he would do good but he would fall in the end also because again, this is a battle that superman enjoys.
no he wasnt dont make stuff up...it never once says this...all i saw was that they said they only had one shot at stoping him, and that was by distraction...hulk could not do it himself
if the hulk was holding back then y did he slam the surfer into the ground like a savage beast
I am inclined to agree with this.
First of all, nobody brawls like Big Blue, so he's #1.
Thor comes in second because he is a warrior at heart and also an experienced brawler.
Now, while Surfer is no slouch when it comes to durability or h2h or physical strength, 1) brawling is simply not his thing; and 2) he is a pacifist at heart. I think he'd make a damn good showing, and quite possibly, he may even be least hurt by this ruckus. But I just don't see the tenacity to out-brawl two top-tier bricks. At best, I could see Surfer perhaps stalemating Thor, but only by applying ABC logic to Surfer/Thor/Hulk fights.
Could Surfer amp his way to a win? Theoretically, I suppose he could, especially if he has some breathing room. But for what it's worth, I tend to envision these fights as might actually be written in a comic, so that's why I go with these results.
__________________
Shinier than a speeding bullet.
I'm assuming this is classic Thor. And if it is... assuming this is supposed to be a physical brawl, is Thor not allowed to pull a Durok Buster?
Also... I had a random flash. One day... when Surfer is in a fit of rage... I'd really like to see him just grab his board and start wailing on someone with it. That'd be some sight to see in a comic...
Gender: Male Location: Ontario
but still reppin naija
Surfer while being considerably the most durable would probably finish last cuz of his lower H2H fighting skills. Superman has got lower H2h skills than thor but he is faster so hed win that battle.
__________________
All thanks goes to starlock.
"Beware trolls, know me and know fear"
KMC Community Forums
Jul 15th, 2008 06:01 PM
