Originally posted by Digi
Well then that's not a critique of labels, just a critique of stupid people. 😉But agreed in full, though I don't think it knocks my earlier argument much. I just remember making a thread in the music forum once where I invented a label in order to try to describe the style of music I enjoyed, in hopes that others would know of such music and we could all learn of new bands and such. Instead I was just roundly insulted and mocked for coming up with a new "useless" label. It seemed counter-productive, to say the least.
touche, however, wouldn't your argument be something like "genres could be useful, though people will mess them up", like, most Utopian ideas, lol.
I don't know though. It may just be stupid people, but genres are totally personal constructs, so their existence is through the collective agreement of stupid people. You cannot separate the one from the other, as "genres" cannot exist outside of human evaluations. LOL, take that post-modernism!