Setting one: Death Star Detention Block C
Combatants:
Mara Jade Skywalker
As of the end of Sacrifice, Mara Jade was one of the most powerful and deadly combatants in the galaxy.
Darth Sidious
At the end of Revenge of the Sith, Sidious has revealed himself as a Sith Lord of considerable skill.
The two will fight to the death in the pits of the Sith's greatest superweapon.
Setting Two: Kavan Caves, Hapes Cluster
For anyone doubting the "most Powerful Sith Lord" can be challenged in any way, suppose that Mara is bloodlusted just as she was against Darth Caedus.
Though her focus is centered on her erstwhile nephew, her thoughts drift through the years back to the other major Sith Lord that threatened her galaxy. When put into a life or death combat situation, Mara considers Palpatine a precedent. The idea that she feels responsibility for his actions and her own inaction lends credence to the idea that, in her professional opinion, her ultimate set of skills and abilities would have been sufficient to kill the powerful Sith lord years in advance of his eventual demise. I intend to prove that Mara's brand of brawling and badassery would be sufficient, in certain circumstances, to destroy the most powerful Sith Lord the galaxy had ever known.
Of Palpatine, I do not need to say much. I will note that as of RotS, he had touched a lightsaber maybe three times in the past decade. Gideon's Palpatine Essay does a far better job than I would of enumerating the many ways in which Darth Sidious's scholarship of the Force put him among the very top tier of mystics.
Mara, the beneficiary of an older Palpatine's training, is not a mystic. Rather, she has a very particular set of skills, skills she acquired over a very long career. Skills that make her a nightmare for people like Palpatine. It is my contention that the degree of bloodlust displayed in the Kavan caves illustrates a combatant capable of DPS far in excess of what most combatants are prepared for. Let's look at that fight scene first:
For reference, Jacen is uniquely tolerant to pain, having survived and transcended the embrace of pain during the events of "Traitor:"
Jacen endured torture and interrogation without respite for days on end without the aid of the Force. Among all of the combatants discussed here, I cannot think of anyone who even rivals this feat. And yet Mara nearly floored him with her first attack. Her tactics put one of the most durable combatants in the galaxy on the defensive without warning. That last bit is particularly important; Jacen was known to be particularly perceptive and talented in manipulation of the Force. (He even managed to create a telepathic link with creatures dead to the Force.) For all his esoteric abilities, Jacen was unable to sense Mara or his impending doom via the Force.
This is a vital point. Sidious, in his duel with Windu, commented on the Jedi's sudden awareness of a third party's emotions (Anakin's fear). In the novelization, Sidious is as aware of Windu's thought patterns as the Jedi is himself. To fight an opponent without that awareness will be a disadvantage we have not seen him cope with before.
Mara is all about generating disadvantages. Beyond the surprise attack, she was very specific about the terrain in which she would fight Jacen. She set traps, only engaging on her own terms. Specifically, close quarters combat, designed to limit his opportunity to use the Force, was the order of the day. Even when battered by the far-more-powerful Force titan with relatively obscure tactics ("Force jolt her spine") she deflects everything and takes the fight to the ground. Palpatine would not last nearly long as did Caedus if the fight got to the point where "it was a brawl."
Caedus himself was rather dismissive of Mara's talents, but she had high level mastery over many Force powers, and the ability to use many of them at once.
Mara is shown to be capable of sustaining (under severe distracting factors) multiple Force powers at once. While this does not put her on the same level as Palpatine or Yoda, in conjunction with her defense against Caedus's attacks it does illustrate that her mastery of the Force is sufficient to defend her against titanic Force abilities.
Mara's proven ability to deal with powerful Force users, along with the truly barbaric fighting style displayed in post 2/3, afford her a place among the galaxy's most effective killers. While I do not believe and will not argue that she would survive an arena match with Palpatine, any situation which allows her the close-quarters combat style displayed in the Kavan caves will end with a dead Palpatine. She can hide herself effectively in the Force, and she can equalize skill differences in Force and Blade ability. She is perfectly situated to kill the Emperor.
I believe that Sidious knows a thing or two about Mara's talents.
Sidious is also more powerful and skilled combatant then Jacen. Even if we consider intelligence, it is one of his strong points. Yes! Jacen can fight dirty - but Sidious employs tremendous speed, reflexes, offensive ferocity, and Strength in the Force. If Sidious exhausted Yoda with his powers, Mara have little hope.
So unless, Mara gets massive circumstances based advantage to begin with, she does not stands a chance.
It is also difficult to assume that Mara would be able to fight on her own terms against Sidious. Because Sidious is a strategist too.
Also, Sidious can collapse sections of tunnels or other constructions over Mara - given his strength in the Force OR may counter similar moves by Mara with his powers. His powers are very effective in offensive sense. Several times we have seen that Sidious can trap even powerful Force-wielders with his powers.
How would Mara manage to break free from lets say - prolonged Force Lightning barrage from Sidious?
However, it is possible that Mara may manage to prolong the fight with her talents and find the opportunity to injure Sidious, at least, in a setting like Kavan Caves by denying him the opportunity to take her out early on or slow down his advances.
But if Sidious decides to win and Mara is alone, you can do the math.
Last edited by S_W_LeGenD on Jun 15th, 2012 at 08:37 AM
Regardless of this being ROTS Sidious, he is still more powerful than any version of Mara Jade.
You also have to take in to account that Mara was raised by pretty much this version of Sidious and recieved all of her training from him or the best he could find in her other areas of training. All the training she did after with the NJO was built around the foundation put in place by Sidious.
DE Luke was good enough to beat the most powerful version of Sidious.
We know that DE Luke was more powerful than any other Jedi during his battle against Palpatine - but flash forward 25+ years, and some of the top-tier Jedi who were promising talents in the Force like Luke (think Kyle, Mara, etc.) at this point would be logically at the same level or likely surpassing that of DE Luke - who defeated Sidious at his Prime.
Zampanó has something here - if Mara is say, more powerful than Kyle (And remember, she was trained by Kyle later on and went through just as much strife as he did in her adventures) then I see her definitely putting her foot up RotS Sidious's ass - after an extremely tough fight.
Mara wins this - but she's scratched up and bleeding, afterwards.
__________________ There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba
- I'll add that Mara has defeated a deadly and Dark side-empowered Kyle before.
Yeah, mathematically, Mara has cleared the power-gap here - she stands at least on even footing with Sidious, no matter how you slice it.
__________________ There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba
Read my posts again - plus (and I didn't notice this before - but the only reason Caedus really won was because of that illusion of Ben he was able to cast into her mind, and the poison he injected into her) if Caedus hadn't been able to use the illusion and poison at just the right time - Mara would have murdered him.
This puts her on even ground with Caedus - who is more powerful than Peak Kyle - who would logically (if you read the books and played the games, but if you haven't, you might not get this) be just as, or more powerful than DE Luke.
Incorrect. Luke Skywalker is the Force God and perfect in every conceivable way.
There is no way Leia used Battle Meditation in that duel - and there is no way you can prove it.
I mean, the radio-drama (Empire's End) states she used Battle Meditation, but why would we believe that?
__________________ There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba
Do you know what the difference between DE Luke and FotJ Luke is?
I think ares834 is under the assumption none of that matters.
__________________ There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba
Yes i know of the difference in power between these two incarnations of Luke, however i still feel DE Luke would defeat Kyle although it would not be as easy.
No. Kyle would break him down, after a tough fight.
Peak Mara as well.
__________________ There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba
Yeah, Kyle may be good, but he's not great. All in all, you can compare him to Kenobi, just without the saber skills.
Frankly, I think most of the Jedi Council by FotJ have reached just below DE Luke in terms of power, and its all from just being trained for years upon years. Luke was still a relative novice at that time. The fact he beat Sidious, even under BM, is still pretty impressive.
However, I think that if Mara goes at this the same way she went after Caedus, she has a chance. Caedus just barely got that dart in time, and he is also physically stronger than Sidious. Does Mara get any prep time?
For Lea's BM believers. I've done some research.
Here all the quotes from audio:
Dark Empire I - BM not mentioned.
Leia observing duel: "Be careful, Luke! The Force is strong.... they’re both moving so fast, I can hardly see them.... I feel waves of power.... the Dark Side and the Light...But...I feel...the Light...is winning!!"
Leia after Force Storm began: "But we can, Luke. We can do it. That’s what the Holocron meant. Let me add my power to yours. "
Dark Empire II:
LUKE: A little. Something about.... "Jedi Battle Meditation." I should study this book. I should study all these books.
Empire's End:
LEIA: This book is important, Han. It teaches the ancient Jedi Battle Meditation techniques. Threepio is helping me translate it.
THREEPIO: Very well. This section tells of a great Jedi Knight named Nomi Sunrider, who learned the art of Battle Meditation during the conflict of...
Conclusion
From audio books it is clear that Lea did not use BM during Luke's duel with Palpatine and utilized Force Harmony (which is not BM either) only after Force storm. Moreover, she started learning BM only in empire's end.
Take that Battlemaster. ;D
Force Harmony would help more than BM as it is said to protect against Dark side powers, along with severing Dark side users from the Dark side. Therefore Luke gets an even bigger help from Leia than i thought.