Jason Aaron's a great writer, I'm so glad he's started writing for Marvel because his work on Scalped is awesome. He fits a Punisher book personally, if you ask me.
I said if it's not Ennis on this book, I'm not interested. Someone then said he was garbage, you said he's overrated. Being garbage is different to being overrated.
Frank Miller, in general, is overrated. Is he garbage? Precisely.
Well if you want to make such a distinction between what you would consider to be garbage and what you would consider to be overrated, I'll happily oblige by placing Ennis in both categories, myself.
It's relevant because opinions of Ennis have been prevalent throughout the last few posts on this thread and there isn't "Is Garth Ennis Garbage or Overrated?" thread to post in
Alson how is ennis not garbage? he the same man who thought a group of killer midgets cutting off peoples legs was a good and interesting plot story......when it was rather stupid and far from clever.
He also the same man who some how had Punisher subdue the hulk and had a view bombs take hulk out......he also the same dude who ignored DD super senses and wolverine and spiderman spidersenses through out the arc to the point they culd not locate punisher who was 30 feet away.......which is utter rediculousness. He also the same dude who ahd spiderman tricked by fake bombs, and had wolverien drink acid.......with out realizing it.
he not clever, his story tend to suck, there far from funnny thoguh he tries to make them so. he also tends to compeltely ignore powers individuals posses and has been quoted statingn he hates heros with powers. Dude not only bias, but he allows his bias to effect his stories. He tends to lack professionalism from what I have gathered from his work, and he hyped to reiddulous levels, most of his sotry arnt funny, nor clever even though he tries to make them so, he garbage compared to most writers and aron
stories will be far better and more clever then ennis ever were.
-BH
Last edited by Dum Dum Dugan on Jul 21st, 2009 at 12:30 AM
Only thing that i've liked from Ennis so far is his run on Punisher Max and Marvel Knights i've seen his work on The Boys and preacher he just seems to think Over the top violence ad showing off naked superheroines and superheroines asking for blowjobs will sell a comic.
Holy terrible spelling and grammar, Batman. Don't sit there critiquing the man's intellect when you can barely string a coherent sentence together.
Anyway, I never said Ennis was good at writing everyone, did I? He obviously has shitty ideas of Hulk, Daredevil and others. The man isn't perfect and I never said he was, you fool.
I simply said that if it's not him writing Punisher MAX, which I feel he DID do amazingly, then I'm not interested.
If you can't keep up with what I'm saying, go to the kiddy table.
KMC Community Forums
Jul 18th, 2009 05:45 AM
