quote: (post)

Originally posted by Soljer
In a straight up fight, I'd say Captain America would take Batman, and Robin would take Punisher.

Then Steve could beat Robin.

However, with the hour of preparation? Batman takes it - he doesn't even need the pedo-tastic boy wonder.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Kurash
with an hour of prep batman takes it

with no prep id say its a split 5/10

Batman and Robin have teamwork on their side, and Cap and Punisher dont really get along

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Team 2. Frank lays down hidden explosives throughout the "arena" before the Bat team gets there.

Then blows them up.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
Team one all day. Bat team scouts the location and wears more protection than usual. They also bring more shuriken and take out Frank first since bullets won't do anything to either of them. While Frank is knocked out and handcuffed, they set their eyes Capt America. Rogers throws his shield, they both duck and double batkick followed by double bat punch and shuriken and Rogers is down and out.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Hm. Ducking the shield.

I wonder why no one ever thought of this handy little method before?

Edit: Not to say that some characters can't duck the shield, but you really could've made it sound like there would be a bit more effort on the Bat team's part there. It's not as if Cap just tosses it willy-nilly. There is a science to it, afterall.