Ok I know this has been done many a time but I just want to see who you people think will win
Thor vs Superman
Ironman vs Green Lantern(Kyle Rayner)
Wasp vs Atom
Namor vs Aquaman
Captian America vs Batman(h2h for this one)
Wonder Man vs Booster Gold
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantana
Quicksilver vs Flash(Barry Allen)
Hercules vs Matian Manhunter
Black Panther vs Wildcat
Warbird vs Wonder Woman
Mr. Fantasic vs Plastic Man
Thor vs Superman = Tie
Ironman vs GL Kyle = GL Kyle...although the crossover makes that somewhat...nevermind
Captain America vs Batman = Cap because the SSS doesn't let him run out of stamina...I think
Scarlet Witch vs Zantana = The Zas babe
Quicksilver vs Barry = Barry stomps
Hercules vs MM = MM unless he decides to slug it out
Warbird vs Wonder Woman = Don't remember who Warbird is
Mr. Fantastic vs Plastic Man = Plastic man, but if we're talking prep Reed solos everyone.
Don't know much about Wildcat to come up with a winner.
Wonder Man vs Booster Gold...Hmm dunno.
Wasp vs Atom = Atom.
Sub-Mariner vs Aquaman = Aquaman 6-7/10
About Supes vs Thor I forgot about current Thor wielding the Thorforce so yeah Thor wins.
__________________
Many thanks to Rao Kal-EL Da Man
Last edited by Zack Fair on Oct 15th, 2008 at 03:39 PM
Some of these aren't that fair, and Wild Cat isn't a JLA member. But
The Winners are
Thor
Green Lantern
Atom
Namor
Cap
Wonder Man
Hawkeye
Zatanna
Flash
Manhunter
Black Panther
Wonder Woman
Plastic man
Thor has Odinforce so he could take Supes for the majority, unless Clark grabs his hammer and beats the snot out of thunder gods
Green Lantern
Atom
Aquaman
Cap and Batman too close to call for me
Wonder Man
Hawkeye
Zantana unless it's HoM Wanda
Flash
MM
Not sure about Wildcat and BP
Wonder Woman
Plastic Man
In an all out fight JLA take out most Avengers in a few seconds due to speed advantages.
If you take regular showings (not HOM\Avengers Disassembled with uber-crazy Wanda), average Zatanna>average Wanda. That's no bias, regular Wanda wasn't teh uberest there is.
Also, I'd like to discuss the possibility of mindrape which is basically an autowin for Aquaman- Namor isn't the best when it comes to resisting mindrapes. That's why in that sparring I vote for Aquaman. Win via mindraping the opponent is as valid as any other one there?
No Aquaman has telepathy to fend off a powerful version of Despero he's like the number 3 telepaths in most version ofthe Jla if you don't count Dr.Fate.
That's what I mean. He doesn't simply "control fish", he has full developed TP effective against any being that has evolved from marine life (directly affecting specific sections of the brain, so "willpower" argument is useless there).
Thor vs Superman
Ironman vs Green Lantern(Kyle Rayner)
Wasp vs Atom
Namor vs Aquaman Captian America vs Batman(h2h for this one) Wonder Man vs Booster Gold
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantana
Quicksilver vs Flash(Barry Allen)
Hercules vs Matian Manhunter Black Panther vs Wildcat
Warbird vs Wonder Woman
Mr. Fantasic vs Plastic Man