Majestic can't be weakness-ed around like Surfer could do with Superman or Gladiator, or others like them. He's a shade under Supes' total offensive output, but has none of his weaknesses, and is arguably more skilled.
Surfer stomps! it doesn't matter if he doesn't have a weakness surfer could exploit! surfer has a huge offensive advantage and is more durable! when amped he can become far stronger! majestic dies in 10 seconds!!!
Surfer has the ability to sense weaknesses in his opponents. He did this to Gladiator.
As for the statement with Majestic not being able to get weakened is false. When he fought a a amped up Atom man he showed signs of getting tired and hurt. So that was false.
Also Majestic lost to Raven of the Teen Titans. So I think Surfer can take him. However Majestic I think wins this.
I see. I wouldn't compare Majestic to Superman however I would do it the other way around. Majestic is Superman but just better really. So to compare Majestic to Superman kind of confused me. Either way Surfer won't try and make radiation to any being who has similar like Superman powers.
__________________
Humans are afraid of the dark.
And yet… At the same time, we’re fascinated and bewitched by it.
Maybe that’s why humans drink the darkness that is coffee.
General stuff:
Yes, Majestros wins with lots of prep. He actually once made a matter manipulator in about 2 fast-moving pages of prep (i.e. a matter of seconds), among other things. And yes, he could throw down with Surfer for a long time in normal mode. Both are legit planet-busters. And when I said he doesn't have Supes' weaknesses, I meant you couldn't drain him of a solar charge, or hit him with K-nite or red sun energy, or magic-based attack or telepathy. For all his power, Kal has some fairly well-documented weaknesses.
So no loophole wins with Majestros. Surfer would have to straight out-fight him. Do-able, but not assured.