Registered: Feb 2005
Location: Hiding from zombies
Sure it would. Victory for Luke. He gets to run off to the swamp and perhaps learn some moves that just might confuse his father enough to score a lethal blow.
Yeah well, i was just trying to point out the concept that if you are fighting somebody and you run away like a sissy, that does not really count as a victory. I did not say, hey if Luke runs away to the swamp, trains and learns new abilities, then re-challenges Anakin and beats him, that is no victory.
Registered: Feb 2005
Location: The Dark Side of the Force
basically everyone here agrees that Anakin will annihilate Luke
__________________
"Beneath this mask there is more than flesh. Beneath this mask there is an idea, Mr. Creedy, and ideas are bulletproof." (Thanks TRiNiTYfemi for the sig!)
I keep re-thinking this and considering Obi-Wan had the skills to turn Anakin's strength's against him, I think Luke, (at this point has surpassed episode 3 Obi-Wan) would actually get the W.
__________________ "The ability to destroy a planet is insignificant, next to the power of the force."
Lukes weak and stupid, i still think to this day that Vader should of beat him in ROTJ, Vader has had years of experence with the force and with the use of his light sabre, and Lukes had what?!?! like 1/2 weeks Jedi training with Yoda what i felt kinda stupid. And Vader got beaten, hes not even that old ffs, Vader was what? 40-50? thats not that old
Luke would gets his ass handed to him by a youngling from the mighty bear clan. There are plenty of times in Empire and ROTJ where Vader could have easily striked down Luke but that wasn't his goal. He wanted to turn his son not kill him. Just watch the movie and count how many times Vader has the opportunity to kill the farmboy but holds back.
__________________ Pointing at the moon does not make you the moon.
You forget that Anakin is a lot stronger than Darth Vader! That's also why the emperor was dissapointed...DV still had Anakin's hatred, but not his strength, than the emperor came up to replace him with Luke. Maybe Luke is stronger than Darth Vader, but not as Anakin.
__________________
"The greatest hero is the one who learns to face his fears and overconquers it!"
bullshit, you think that luke would loose because episode 6 was made when there were not so good effects, if they would be making it now, they would make such a fight, that there would be no argues,basically anakin in ROTS is the same as Darth Veder in ROTJ, the only difference is that there were no video effects to make fight better, and one more thing it is not realated to post, but anyway, Windu will kick everybody's ass. By the way Luke clearly kicked his father's ass in episode 6.