do u read the books? james had died first, when the wands connected lily would come out first and tell harry to holdon and that his dad is coming out (please log in to view the image)
Well i think that James Died first. But im not completly shur about that. all i know is that Lily defended Harry before he killed her. so James was most likly dead.
Remember how Voldemort told her to get out of the way. and she refused?
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
no I've read that part 9 times and it's harry's dad that comes out of the wand first because if you'd have read it Harry's dad comes out and tells him that his mother is coming and it is her that tells harry what to do
i have the book next to me
i quote:
the smoky shadow of a young woman withlong hair fell to the groundas bertha had done , straightened up, and looked at him.....and harry, his arms shaking madly now looked backinto the ghostly face of his mother
your farther's coming ...she said quietly. he wantsto see you... it will be alright... hold on
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
maybe the book in the USA not the same as the English version.there are slight variations i read some where
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
__________________
I've got a pal, she's called Pixie,From Birmingham where they're all trixxy, ((fun))She thinks she can't spell,
I say "What the hell?"Doesn't matter because she's damn sexy!!
By syren
OK, some clarification. In the first edition of Book 4, the editors messed it up and put the echoes in the wrong order. In the later editions it is corrected and James was indeed killed first. Also note that Harry heard the Phoenix song for the SECOND and not the third time in his life. That is also corrected in later editions. The early US versions on PoA made a mistake; they said that Voldemort has been in hiding for 15 instead of 12 years. I presume this has been corrected too.
KMC Community Forums
Jan 27th, 2004 10:21 PM
