Okay, we're not sure 100% that he'll come back. But JKR may think that the chance and the hope of his comeback will make us read Book 6 and Book 7. But for heaven's sake, the only thing she has to do to make the world read her books is write. Do I make any sense?
__________________ "You didn't believe in me. But I believed in myself. Just like the last scene of all movies."
Yeh you do, i like the thoery about snape making a potion although i'm not really sure that he would do it for harry, seeing as he has never liked sirius black in the first place but maybe dumbledore will pursade him seeing as dumbledore has always known that sirius black is innocent. I am definetley sure that the next book can explain the real truth about sirius and i trust that sirius isn't totally dead because JK wouldn't cut him outta harry's life 4ever.
N XXX
ok my thoery is that when he (sirius) was hit with a curse, it was not a green light that came from the wand it was red, so therefore it wasn't the killing curse, it must have stunned him which made him fall down the stone steps and through the vale of mysteries, (if thats what its called) cant remember its been a while since ive read the 5th book! and....since no-one knows where that vale leads, or anything that it does and while JK hasnt stated thats its a good thing that hes behind a vale that no-one knows about im confussed slightly but i do believe that hes not dead! so there is a ray of hope, Amen, praise the lord!
well i do believe that sirius will come back. if jk never explained to us what really did happen to him then how can anyone actually say to us that he did die in the last book, i think we need to concentrate on what actually happened when he fell down the hole in the order of the phoenix.
Post your comments so that we can all come to some sort of conclusion for this MYSTERY- LOL!
Gender: Male Location: England; at least it's not the U.S.
JKR said she was upset when she wrote him out of the novels, thus reducing the likelihood of a return. Furthermore someone was supposed to die in OOtP - if it wasn't Sirius, who was it? We aren't seeing Sirius again. Unlucky.
JK isn't exactly going to tell us tons of information about sirius's death and of course she is like really upset about writing him outta the books i mean i was but i do agree that he won't come back in the way he was included in these books before but what i do think is that his spirit is still going to be included into these books, hmmmm quite SPOOKY.
Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs present you the Mauranders map, where have they all gone to? Peter Petigrew is out there somewhere, maybe he will come back with Sirius?
(Thinking)
He is dead and Dumbledore said it himself "No spell can awake the dead" or something along that line. :P It doesn't make sense, how he can come back if he won't be a ghost. Well, I suggest us Potter fans better, hit the Myth books, and see if we can find the answer,
just because he's dead and he's *we've been told* not coming back to life - doesn't mean harry won't see him again somewhere, i mean harry's always having dreams, and then there's things like the mirror of erised, and those crazy moving photos, and just generally his memory, the penesieve - so i don't reckon sirius is out of the books yet even if he doesn't meet harry again
__________________ "Shame about the French, really. Obsessed with raisins. Humiliated grapes, really. Think about it."
- Captain Jack Sparrow
Just because Dumbledore said that he has gone dosen't mean he is right and if dead people can't turn into ghosts then why has nearly headless nick and the bloody baron and moaning myrtle and all the other dead people turned into ghosts when they died? Why isn't harry's parents ghosts when they have died?
There has to be an answer
Gender: Male Location: England; at least it's not the U.S.
Have you even read the books? Nearly Headless Nick told us why, because only those afraid of death return, and can only wander where they trod as mortals. Sirius was afraid of pretty much nothing, so he aint coming back. Do think before you type.
harry's parents weren't afraid of anything and of course sirius wasn't either like you said and Jk explained that she had to write out someone in the book and she has explained that she will do it again who is also quite close to harry at hogwarts but if she dosen't exactly write how they have died we will never know what to believe. This veil that sirius fell down could lead to anywhere beyond hogwarts like to voldemort which could explain why sirius hasn't come back.
Gender: Male Location: England; at least it's not the U.S.
LOL, no, the veil apparently kills you, because Lupin sure knew what it did, as he immediately prevented Harry from rushing though it, and knew at once that Sirius was dead.
KMC Community Forums
Jun 13th, 2005 04:04 PM
