is dumbledore dead You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
Yes 51 52.58%
No 46 47.42%
Total: 97 votes 100%
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by stormlover Well J.K.'s not going to say that he is definately coming back. It would spoil everything. She might just have said he really died to throw us off and suprise us in the end with him coming back. Has she ever said something before a book came out and it turned out to be false when the book came out?
__________________
06:43 PM
willRules 4 8 15 16 23 42 Gender: Male
Well she isn't go to lie to us so it seems more likely than not that he died. however she still hasn't confirmed if Snape is a god guy or not. If Snape is a good guy, it implies Snape has a plan and since he is taking Dumbledore's orders, it implies Dumbledore has a plan which to work, costs him his life __________________
11:32 AM
allofyousuckkk Amazingly Awesome Gender: Male
i dont understand how someone can stay he's still alive. false hope anyone?
__________________
04:23 PM
Barker Thorin Fan Club President Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by stormlover Has she ever said something before a book came out and it turned out to be false when the book came out?
__________________
05:57 PM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by allofyousuckkk i dont understand how someone can stay he's still alive. false hope anyone?
__________________
06:40 PM
stormlover Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
quote: (post ) Originally posted by The Phantom You can't understand how someone can say he isn't alive? Do we have to remind you JK runs the whole HP thing?
__________________
08:45 PM
Regulus A Black Elder Mormon Gender: Male
actually JKR did say that Snape was a good guy, and she never actually said that Dumbledore was dead, she said "Don't expect him to pull a Gandalf."
__________________
08:45 PM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by The Phantom * (Question about upcoming deaths): You shouldn't expect Dumbledore to pull a Gandalf. I need to be more explicit: Dumbledore is definitely dead. I know there's an entire site out there called DumbledoreIsNotDead.com, and I'm sorry they're not going to like this answer.
__________________
08:49 PM
Regulus A Black Elder Mormon Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by The Phantom Ok.... READ THIS AGAIN! What does it say? It says she said he is dead.
__________________
09:00 PM
stormlover Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
quote: (post ) Originally posted by stormlover That means that she can say something about the book now and then change her mind about it later, right?
__________________
09:02 PM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Regulus A Black actually if i remember correctly that part where she says he actually is dead, was added later by reporters
quote: (post ) Originally posted by stormlover Right?
__________________
09:09 PM
allofyousuckkk Amazingly Awesome Gender: Male
she wouldn't be so blunt about it had it been untrue. If we can't believe the author, what can we believe?
__________________
03:58 AM
~KoK!~ Sock Hunter Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by The Phantom Well then.... good. No, it's illegal. We will massacre her if she lied to us.
__________________ W:5|L:2|T:0|
Nothing is true...everything is permitted.
04:25 AM
willRules 4 8 15 16 23 42 Gender: Male
I just read the interview and although Rowling confirms Dumbledore's death she also confirmed that Snape is still a good guy, Dumbledore's death was planned and Dumbledore has a role in helping Harry in book 7 __________________
03:41 PM
stormlover Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
quote: (post ) Originally posted by willRules
I just read the interview and although Rowling confirms Dumbledore's death she also confirmed that Snape is still a good guy, Dumbledore's death was planned and Dumbledore has a role in helping Harry in book 7 __________________
03:48 PM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by stormlover Do you have a link or something
__________________
06:19 PM
allofyousuckkk Amazingly Awesome Gender: Male
phantom, what is your avatar? it looks so familiar
__________________
12:52 AM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by allofyousuckkk phantom, what is your avatar? it looks so familiar
__________________
12:55 AM
Mr Krieger Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/
12:35 AM
The Phantom Angel of Music Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Darth Kreiger
http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/ __________________
01:23 AM
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threadsmay not post repliesmay not post attachmentsmay not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG] code is ON
Text-only version
KMC Community Forums
Aug 4th, 2006 06:43 PM
