The battle of Endor and duel between Vader and Luke are what saved ROTJ in my opinion, because the rest of the movie I felt to be pointless fluff.
I was born after the OT came out, having been born in 1986, yet I still MUCH prefer the OT. I first saw it when I was about 10 years old and within two weeks of having bought the VHSs had watched the entire trilogy 5 times. I never actually saw the SEs until the DVDs came out though, as I'd bought the original VHSs less than a year before and saw no real point in spending that much money again especially as I was so young and that's a lot of cash.
But the OT just is better, I think. Better writing, better directing, better characterization, better plots, better actors...the only thing the PT really has over the OT is the special effect, which ultimately in my opinion mean nothing at all because it always felt to me that Lucas was using all the fun flashy effects to draw attention away from the fact that the movies really were not as good as they could have been.
This is not to say I don't like the PT, because I do. It just isn't as good as the OT, I think.
This is similar to my story, but the PT goes into some areas that the OT just glosses over, like politics, hypocrisy, and the role of the jedi. I think these things do contribute greatly to our understanding of the OT. I like the PT and OT on a fairly equal basis. What the PT has in political philosophy, art direction, and detail the OT makes up for with sometimes decent scripts, acting, and a philisophical direction of its own.
Yes. If you said the words "Star Wars" to people fifteen years ago it would conjure up a completely different image to what people would think of now...
You know what I think was majorly instrumental in the downfall (and I use the word lightly) of Star Wars? Kids. Specifically, Lucas's kids. Think about it... what did we get after Lucas had kids? We got Ewoks, a cheesy musical number, comical and pointless inserts into the SW SE, Jar Jar... All after Lucas started his family. ROTJ, IMO is a noticeably different tone to ANH and ESB... much closer to TPM.
Haha, I can just imagine PT lovers who don't like the OT.
"yeah, the prequels were so much better with incredible romantic scenes and the yoda/sidious fight was fantastic! Two Force giants battling each other? What more could you want? It was a spectacular battle. Never have we seen the huge power of the Force such we did then. They were throwing senate pods as if they were frisbees. Lightning blasts, and Yoda catches it and throws it back. Fantastic.
And it was a "teachable moment" too. Yoda and Sidious battled to a draw. But Yoda says he failed. Yoda wanted to defeat Sids, but because it was a draw, he says he failed. That's honesty and leadership for you."
PT lovers sound pretty gay to me just like the fanboys start to sound more gay by the day.
As an aside, I was killing time watching Beverly Hills Cop III today, and there in an amusement park was The Maker himself, George Lucas, as a guy whom Axel cut in front of to get on a ride.
So I IMDB'd it and there Lucas was, and so was Joe Dante. Landis was the director, so I was half expecting Spielberg to be in the credits too, but he wasn't there. However, there was Forrest J Ackerman, Arthur Hiller, Ray Harryhausen, and composer Robert Sherman! Lucas was with an actress called Christina Venuti.
I don't get it; it was a terrible movie, but had all these behind-the-lenses hollywood types in cameos.
CG is the shit cuz that is what mr lucas would have done in '78!
by the way what is lukes shoe size?
i love all 6 star wars!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
__________________ its beef lady 50 pounds of beef
Noone know's Lucas's shoesize. After his ego was inflated by his own success, his feet followed suit.
__________________ Recently Produced and Distributed Young but High-Ranking Political Figure of Royal Ancestry within the Modern American Town Affectionately Referred To as Bel-Air.
Registered: Sep 2003
Location: the bad side of the moon
it was the only star from the OT that held its own in the PT. agree 150% . Johnny will never do anything suck-ass. its not in his character, h will continue to write sensational scores until the day he dies.
I don't know, Chinabing or whatever the hell his name is suddenly starts whining about why famous people want to cameo in a movie he finds boring. I thought maybe because Eddy Murphy is such a famous guy, everybody is his friend and it was probably his birthday.
Whatever, I really don't give a F*CK!!