i can't believe only 7% said liz!! she hasn't even had any training(or at least the movie hasn't said so) and she would've killed all of davy jones' crew in 2 minutes if they weren't undead.
__________________
MapleSugar is my hero Join the Raver Club! Now
Isen grädde smörgås
Striking a key is one thing but to hold a sword is another. You actually think that Davy can fight with all these swords with his tentacles but yet you have no proof so again Davy is an unknown.
Jack is the best fighter but Will is the best sword fighter
his tentacles aren't that long they would have him in reach and he would be exposing his head for attacks since he would have to move it forward when striking and from what we can tell the can't grow bigger. Besides how strong are his tentacles anyway? I doubt they'll hold swords. Maybe they can throw knives that I can picture. I imagine he'll have the Yoda effect. But since I haven't seen him yet I'm going with Will since it's just sword fighting in an all out battle if Barbossa and Davy Jones can be killed Jack would more then likely win. Though Elizabeth is also pretty damn tough and skilled.
__________________ I've got a Charisma of 23, max ranks and skill focus in Seduction, and I just rolled a 17. Are we doing it yet?
i had to go with Will as the best all-around swordsman, but his weakness is that he plays by the rules.
i am more partial to the Jack method of swordfighting---- confusing and manipulating your opponent, like he does with will:
"do you really think this wise boy? crossing blades with a pirate?" AKA Jack is trying to get out of fighting him at all
In the list I have to say Elizabeth is the worse. Everyone else has years of exprience in sword fighting like Barbossa who kept Jack on full defense throughout their fight.
I voted for Will mainly because he has more skill a just a sword fighter
I think she could take on Pintel and Ragetti seperately of course maybe together they aren't very strong just pirates who are more of comic relief. if Barbossa and Norrington are on the same level then she can't take Norrington. But I can't see how they are on the same level
__________________ I've got a Charisma of 23, max ranks and skill focus in Seduction, and I just rolled a 17. Are we doing it yet?
I'm pretty sure Norrington is a great sword fighter. Him and Will went toe to toe and niether managed to gain the upper hand throughout their fight. And straight up sword fighting Will is better then all the others so that says that Norrington is a great sword fighter.
Why is everyone saying Jack. Is it just because he's the favorite? ESB is right, dvd commentary lets us know that Jack is the worst fighter of all of them. This isn't a "who would win altogether" but "who is the best sword-fighter" thread. Therefore the answer canonically is Will, then Barbossa and Norrington, followed by Jack.
I would imagine Davy Jones could kick ass with a sword. If he could hold one.
ESB is the one to listen too here, he seems to know most about the fighting. Whereas Jack was overwhelmed during the 3 way duel, Norrington and Will battled it out - with Will having a slight edge.
KMC Community Forums
Join the Raver Club! Now 
Jul 26th, 2006 11:05 PM
Attachment: 
if Barbossa and Norrington are on the same level then she can't take Norrington. But I can't see how they are on the same level
