quote: (post)

Originally posted by Citizen V
Judges Vote

I have to congratulate both participants of this final for getting this far, both of you have proved you are very good debaters in the past and I was very much looking forward to this. Two good amalgams, led by two good debaters (it wasn't much of a surprise to see you two against each other in a final again).

I think that HK was on the back foot from the start of this fight straight away, a lot of his points seemed like they wouldn't hold up against Bigfoot (aka the phasing thing, I couldn't see Stark successfully using either of those gadgets to harm him and the sonics wouldn't work as Big foot's character was too large. The inertia thing was smart on Blair's part, but as Scoob pointed out Big foot's strength wouldn't be hindered by it because of his control of gravity via the moonstones.

I think it could have been a great match, but real life comes first to be honest, it stalled a match I was really looking forward to if I'm being honest.

In the end, Blair's offensive was really lacking in the brute firepower it would need to put Bigfoot down and never really showed anyway to breach his defences. Scoob on the other hand had a very convincing defense and his offensive was simple and effective, so.. therefore I cast my vote to:

SCOOBLESS

Well played gentlemen, well done to the both of you .

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Galan007
Judges Vote:


As stated in other matches I've judged, I'm not one for essays.... So this will be short, sweet, and to the point...


Blair,

You came up with some very good tactics here, such as the already mentioned "inertia move", but I felt as though your offense left something to be desired against Bigfoot. It seemed like the sheer damage you'd need to put Scoobs amalgam down, just wasn't there.



Scoobs,

Your plans/strategies seemed better rounded. You had the total package as far as this match went, [ie. a good offense/defense, and you knew exactly what your amalgam could do, and how it could help you here].


In short,

My vote goes to Scoobles.



Great job to the both of you, and congratulations for getting here!

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Badabing
Judge's Vote

Blair Wind- You made the best use of your amalgam. Every match you were changing tactics and using different powers, resources and combinations of both. I liked your amalgam's use of tech, brains and powers. You were able to adapt to almost every situation in the tourny.

Scoobless - Your amalgam wasn't the most exotic or complex but you used its powers to the fullest. Blunt force is the best way to describe your character and you used clever techniques to change up your game plan as the tourny progressed.

My decision came down to this: Blair's plan was solid for a 500 ft BF but not a 10 mile and growing BF which is hovering a mile above and raining attacks from the start. The weapons Blair brought during the prep were inadequate to stop BF IMO. My vote goes to:

Scoobless

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Scoobless
Oh, and I suppose I should mention that it was Digi who actually named Bigfoot ... none of the names I came up with sounded anything but retarded. I didn't actually like the name "Bigfoot" either to begin with, although it did eventually start to grow on me (no pun intended)

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Scoobless
Oh, and I suppose I should mention that it was Digi who actually named Bigfoot ... none of the names I came up with sounded anything but retarded. I didn't actually like the name "Bigfoot" either to begin with, although it did eventually start to grow on me (no pun intended)

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Scoobless
All votes are final dammit.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Scoobless
It irks me that you both found two completely different parts of that single paragraph to complain about.



*damn literary Nazis*

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Scoobless
It irks me that you both found two completely different parts of that single paragraph to complain about.



*damn literary Nazis*

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Galan007
Pfft...

The only reason I voted for you was because of your amalgam's name.... Now I just feel betrayed.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Badabing
Edit: At least we didn't mind this part, "none of the names I came up with sounded anything but retarded."