quote:

darthgoober wrote on Oct 5th, 2008 06:07 AM:
Voting for Kandy & id, but just barely.

As far as I'm concerned, the scan with Nate talking about the link working both ways doesn't amount to much because Nate isn't anywhere on the battlefield and that kind of thing varies in it's portrayal. It's a lot like showing a scan of Sentry being unable to lift the Helicarrier due to a lack of tactile tk as proof that Thor or Herc couldn't lift something that big because they also lack it(not an exact parallel, but hopefully you get my point). Different writers have different standards on that kind of thing and it just doesn't fly with me to try to carry that kind of thing over from character to character.

Fish's plan wasn't without flaws of its own though. If Electo's field is running at 7,000 degree's and he turned it on during his prep when they were all grounded in the Amazon Jungle it'd start a massive forest fire that would likely cook his Taskmaster/Sabretooth before the match itself even started.

So even though Fish's plan is much simpler and more direct, I'm going to have to give it to KK and id because their plan had a lot less chance of backfiring right out of the gate and I see their defensive use of Spot's powers as fairly believable and hard to get around.

quote:

Symmetric Chaos wrote on Oct 4th, 2008 08:19 PM:
Kandy/id369 Vs. Kfish

Very good debating by both parties but unfortunately the battle was one sided. Kfish did not present an argument that I felt was sufficient to counter the defense presented by the Spot cube while dealing with the variety of attacks being thrown at him, no matter how poorly aimed those attacks might be.

Vote: Kandy/id369