Gender: Male Location: Cape Cod Massachusetts/United State
Tough to say for sure. This could really go either way. However, I see team 2 taking the slight majority. While Wally is the fastest, team 2 has more speed overall.
I see it playing out something like this.
Team 1 sends out Superman, Manhunter, and Thor (who opens a portal to the planet, while the other 2 fly there in a few seconds, or minutes tops). Zatana, Flash and Lobo are left to defend the flag, with Zatana placing several spells and illusions around the flag to make it more difficult for team 2 to get it.
Team 2 sends out Surfer, Majestic, and Gladiator to capture the flag, while Beta Ray Bill, Dr. Strange, and Quasar are left to defend the flag. Dr. Strange will also place various spells on their flag to make it more difficult for team 1.
Moving on, Surfer can reach the planet in seconds, if not faster, making him just as fast, or faster than Thor opening a portal to the planet. Majestic and Gladiator wouldn't be too far behind.
Now, say both teams arrive at the others' planet. Wally would do a pretty good job of holding off one of the speedsters from team 2, but he'd be hard pressed to hold off all three. Lobo is perhaps a match, physically, for anyone on team 2, but he doesn't have the speed. Zatana would do alright with keeping up spells on the flag, as well as helping a little with support, but I think team 1's offensive capabilities would overwhelm team 2's defenses, especially if they manage to bfr the flash...at least for a short while anyway.
Team 1s Flag getters definitely have some speed and real power, but with Superman's weakness to magic, I see Dr. Strange being able to contain, or, at least, severely slow him down. This leaves MM and Thor to try for the flag, which Quasar and BRB, could, I believe, hold off. MM could make a difference here though, given his TP abilities. However, I believe, overall, that team 2's defense would do a better job of holding off team 1's offense, while team 2's offense would do a better job of overwhelming team 1's defense...if they broke up the teams the way I've mentioned.
Plus, if Surfer manages to get his hands on the flag, it's a done deal for team 2.
So, I, personally, think team 2 wins this 6, maybe 7/10.