Narnia has an evil witch, large talking lion with a Jesus complex, bunch of children and a sleuth of not so scary monsters.
LOTR has a couple of kickass wizards, hordes of goblins, orcs, orc-men, trolls, ring wraiths; their steeds, gigantic battle elephants, a balrog, dwarves, elves, armies of humans, walking trees and the ****ing Captain of Despair, who is cock-proof.
Aslan is FAR more powerful than a large talking lion...he has shown to be able to alter reality/time/space. For example, he appears larger to larger people and smaller to smaller people...even when they're looking at him at the same time! He also basically destroyed the universe, has stopped time before, etc.
Narnia also has giants.
But to be honest, LOTR might win since this is ALL of middle earth vs Narnia (and not any of the other lands).
Would it be more fair if it were Narnia vs Gondor?
__________________ Introduce a little government. Upset the established gangs, and everything becomes order...
Democracy is the very definition of awesome.
Gender: Female Location: When in Doubt, Go to the Library.
really? we're really asking this question? okay, i'll write it out.
middle earth : orcs; elves; dwarves; hobbits; wizards [of different ranks go up to mostest powerful...]
bow and arrow; wicked swords; daggers; teeth; claws.
[and this is like, 1/1000 of middle earth fighting.
narnia [during lion, witch, wardrobe. .
four untrained children. one is blessed with a gift of arrows that always find their mark....
which is negated by the talent for this sort of combat in one knuckle of one pinky on one elf. [or more likely the bit of nail that was just trimmed]
one is blessed with a potion that can revive people UNLESS they're dead. oh, and by the way, she's about four to six years old.
one is blessed with shield and sword of aslan. is trained well.
one has sword, but also has PTSD because of stay in local witch's castle.
then we've got minotaurs, hags that look like balding chickens, and "deep magic," which conveniently has no steady rules.
magical lion that could cause all sorts of destruction..... but has a tendency to show up only for morale and general petting.
... middle earth? pwns.
It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live.
Jadis has a spell that can kill everything. If they don't have aslan, who can destroy the universe, and jadis doesn't use that spell, then lotr pwnz. Sorry, i know that middle earth is way more awesome and all, but its like pitting sauron vs. Voldemort. Voldemort has the killing curse and can take him out before he reaches him. etc.
But he lacks feats. We don't know exactly how powerful Finarfin was in magic, nor how he conquered the city. Don't get me wrong, I believe that Sauron is far more powerful then Voldemort, but Sauron lacks the feats necessary.
__________________ Thanks starlock for the sig And Morgoth came...