What example of plot induced stupidity (PIS) is your most/least liked in a film?
A lot of people I speak to don't know what plot induced stupidity (PIS) is. Take Star Wars episode IV, for example:
"Hold your fire. Scans indicate no life forms on that escape pod that just launched."
"Sir, we just boarded a mock freighter that is a front for the Rebel Alliance. The Alliance has stolen Death Star plans that they plan to use to overthrow the Imperial government. You're telling me to leave that pod alone, even though we're arresting radical militants with plans of espionage? As if they wouldn't go to any means to protect their plans? How stupid are you, sir?"
"By gum, you're right, gunner. Open fire and blast the shit out of that pod! Lord Vader will give us promotions for this!"
"Yes, sir! Long live the Empire!"
Yeah. If it happened like that, we wouldn't have a saga. Hence, we have PIS.
So many movies have PIS in them. What are some examples of PIS that you like and dislike?
Like: Obi-Wan not finishing off Anakin at the end of ROTS. I'm 0kay with this scene because Obi-Wan is a compassionate person and its clear that despite whats happened he still loves Anakin as a brother and can't bare to crawl down a hill and coldly execute him like that. Its definately an understandable and human mistake for him to make, even if it was really dumb and he should have at least confirmed he was dead before leaving.
Dislike: Anakin or the Jedi never going back for his mother before AOTC. Thats just stupid.
At the beginning of the movie when Sebastian kills Eric's mother.
Eric shows his anguish & rage by killing the 2 soldiers but does NO HARM to Sebastian at all.
He then spends the rest of the movie & his adulthood hunting him down.
Kill Bill - How a group of supposedly elite assassins leave what I would assume to be a hugely dangerous hit alive. I like it because it's just so painfully ironic. The merchants of death who can't even do it right without being paid. They should have kept her, she's apparently the only one beside the cyclops who is any good at her job =D
Indiana Jones; Kingdom of the Crystal Skull - Refridgerator. Nuff said.
I will most certainly be back for more, but these are the only things that come to mind initially. Good thread idea.
Not neccessarily, by that time the Predator was heavily injured like Esau Cairn said, not to mention it didn't have it's invisibility cloak/laser which it relied on far too much. Also, did you see the hardware Harrigan carried around with him? And it's not as if he took it on hand to hand, he had a weapon at all times during his encounters.
If anything, you could say Dutch had PIS working for him more when the Pred was smacking him around like it was a structured fight, considering it aced Billy in an instant who only had a knife.
Last edited by Lord Shadow Z on Sep 29th, 2011 at 03:39 PM
Mine would be another star wars related one...Why didn't obi wan use force speed when qui gonn was fighting maul to get through the force fields in one shot? they were shown to be able to do it when they ran from the roller droids. if he did then qui gonn would still be alive and all the mess afterward would likely have been avoided. numpty
Gender: Female Location: When in Doubt, Go to the Library.
Well, all the Harry Potter films were check your brain at the door unless you read the books, or had someone next to you in the theatre who could explain what was going on. So I don't know if that's a bad thing for the people whose brains had to be checked - or if all the poked holes made for an extremely confusing film set.
Can anyone comment regarding that?
__________________
It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live.
Much of the movie makes no sense. Although this is about Plot Induced Stupidity.
1. The scene where the lone female character goes running out onto the street because she hears her baby crying. She knows full well that her baby is long gone at this point, so this makes this scene extra stupid and obvious. I hate it when movies do this... nose diving moments like this kill the movies.
2. Another one happens later on in the movie when the little boy runs into the church thinking his mom is there... the plot does this so the Hayden Christiansen character gets offed next. Not that that is a real big issue.
Off-topic:
I wish someone would remake this movie... it had some legitimately creepy scenes. The hallway scene with Hayden's character at the news station is one.
Gender: Female Location: When in Doubt, Go to the Library.
The don't blame it on the Joker because it was Dent's decision to go completely mad. That was the point of the "nurse" scene, when the Joker helped Harvey lodge the gun against the Joker's forehead. He sincerely didn't care if he died - he just wanted to knock Dent of the sanity wagon... and once that happened, Two-Face's actions were his responsibility. Through the movie we get an example that perhaps Dent is not the shining knight he is portrayed to be - when he takes off in the ambulance with the paranoid schizophrenic and plays Russian Roulette with him - Batman has to come and explain that he's going to get no where through violence.
__________________
It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live.
Seriously, none noticed how the predator went from being a highly efficiant killer to worthless junk?
I mean it takes out the entire team that is meant to capture it, well aware of what limits it has in regards to it's cloaking, the next scene (where the cop is involved) the predator is suddenly standing like a complete moron "well I guess I never have experienced water before" then Harrigan, by some freaking miracle manages to hit the Predators laser cannon on the first burst fire he unleashes, etc. etc.
I don't feel that both the plight of the mother & later the little boy fell on plot induced stupidity...
Neither the audience or the characters in the movie knew what was happening...or for that matter why it happened & why they seemed to be the only ones left alive.
The only reason & sense of reality both mother & little boy had was that one had a daughter & the other a mother who promised she'd come back. I mean in real life there's still parents who grasp on blind-hope that their missing child would one day just turn up or be found after years have past.
Lastly, I don't think a remake would do it justice. The low budget, the limited acting ability of the cast & the unknown of what actually happened wouldn't hold together with a bigger budget & better cast.
Any movie where tons of bad guys surround the good guy, yet the bad guys only attach one at a time.
One I really like (because it is making fun of the concept intentionally) is Austin Powers when Dr. Evil and Scott argue about how to kill Austin Powers. Scott suggests just shooting him, but Dr. Evil wants to do something slow and elaborate, which gives way for Powers to escape.
__________________
Greg Oden: The future of the Blazers. The future of the NBA.
KMC Community Forums
Sep 28th, 2011 07:30 PM
