What? I said she might be as strong as Kara if we go by Simone's portrayal but then PG looked stronger than her under Mark Waid. How's that being having lack of objectivity regarding to wonder woman?
FWIW in a normal fight I would give diana 6-7/10 on Kara, I think Kara is a bit stronger and more durable than her though. She would win here 6/10 IMO.
It was pretty difficult to find a consistent power level for SG and PG pre-Flashpoint.
Despite presenting the idea that SG only seemed uber relative to Superman because he held back, SG also seemed to drop in power level relative to other heroes post-original push.
Diana could not match Supergirl during her original push--Diana couldn't manhandle the league like SG did when she was Dark Supergirl. But on the whole WW was more often presented as being able to take SG in a fight.
So I don't see how she was supposed to be below wonder woman level when she has actual wins over top tiers in h2h. Ultraman has oneshotted Wonder Woman last they met BTW.
What did I say that was wrong about wonder woman? I am just arguing that Kara was right there with wonder woman in terms of strength till the end albeit slightly stronger. Its not that she was in a different tier or something. I'm genuinely curious about this "lack of objectivity" now.
So I'm just supposed to forget about every other thread where you posted about Diana? Really?
And what about Ultraman? Was it not so long ago that you were arguing with someone about how the Ultraman that Kara beat up wasn't as impressive as the higher up Ultramans?
On average, I would say Kara was stronger, yes. Even for strength, some portrayals may imply an equality - or even superiority- for Wonder woman. But I'd say on the whole SG was stronger. That being said, formidability is more complex.
Aw c'mon pr, its ownage thread and I just stumbled upon a very good comic book archive.
The first Ultraman in Supergirl series was a new character from Earth-3 but this Ultraman which Kara beat in Robinson's JLA was from crime syndicate aka antimatter universe. Don't worry though, Robinson wrote superman treating Supergirl as a spoiled child in strength.
In the very same story she conceded that PG is at least as strong as her. In Waid's B&B PG looked solidly above her in strength with knocking her out and then catching her punch.
Although in the first fight Diana was somewhat poisoned, so its not totally fair. But catching her full punch is totally legit.
KMC Community Forums
Jan 2nd, 2014 01:17 PM
I usually hate Batman pedo jokes, but dammit, that was funny.
