quote: (post)

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Annnd he's back. Just gotta have the last word in huh? Uh uh. Nossirrreee.

1) Lol. That's not what I want you to accept. I want you to admit that your 5-10 ton "best guess" was utterly wrong and had absolutely no basis in evidence. You kept insisting it and even now won't admit that you made an error, instead choosing to move the goalposts and try to make ppl forget that this all started with your 5-10 tons "best guess" BS.

2) Prove it was smaller. Show me screenshots and timestamped vids where parts of it were NOT offscreen. Not just you insisting over and over again, as nobody believes you.

While you're at it, prove that this so-called "smaller version" you keep harping about is factually 5-10 tons. I want calcs and types of rocks (with pics) identical to the one Kurse threw that fit within that estimate. Stop speculating, provide proof.

This is how deep of a hole you dug yourself in. Even if you prove one, you need to prove both, or you are still oh so wrong.

So go ahead, do the work, I'll wait.

3) Lol "common sense". This is what you do when you know you have nothing. You just go "but common sense! duhhh". Pffphtt.

You were being disingenuous providing materials that I did not ask for (I said SOLID material, reread what I requested) and that had nothing to do with we were discussing. Unless you are an absolute moron (w/c I don't believe you are, as I've met actual morons and you don't sound like one, tbh), it was pretty damned obvious I was asking for materials that would weigh 5-10 tons within that volume and that constituted that rock Kurse threw since we were discussing the rock being 5-10 tons and nothing else. Don't whine when, the fact is, you tried to be "clever" only to have it humiliatingly backfire. You rolled the dice, don't whine when it didn't land in your favor.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by h1a8
1. Harping on this is derailing the thread.

2. I gave the scene and time stamp. Did you bother to check it out? If not then I'll give it again, a little later.

3. I wasn't referring to the scene where Kurse threw the boulder in my less than 10 ton estimate. It was in the initial scene where he started to lift it. Also, its makeup is a HUGE part of the estimate. Can you honestly say that the boulder Kurse picked up resembles 100% solid rock? Or did it remember something lighter?

quote: (post)

Originally posted by h1a8
Either you guys are pretty dumb or you just trolling at this point.

1. I'll accept the intention of the writer that the boulder WAS MEANT to be made of solid rock and give the weigh of 150-200 tons. So any other discussion is derailing the thread and is considered flaming.

quote:

2. In the scene Kurse first lifted it, the boulder was indeed smaller than the one in the scene where he is seen throwing it.

quote:

3. It's common sense that the make up of the boulder appears to be a much lighter material than actual solid rock. It could have been part ash, part dirt, part decayed materials, etc. Or it could have been somewhat porous, not completely solid.

quote:

In an attempt to flame me, Nibedicus asked me what material could give a weigh of less than 10 tons. I responded, "feathers, foam, ash, etc." I wasn't referring to the possible makeup of the boulder, just answering the question. He knows this. And chose to quote the response without the question.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
WOW, you'll accept what the movie actually shows. how very generous of you. Now just admit that your guess of 5-10 tons was just you trying to massively downplay the feat.




The entire boulder was shown both before and after Kurse lifted it, it was clearly shown to be very large.




It's only "common sense" to massive biased people that are trying their best to downplay the feat.



Yes, you were.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by h1a8
My less than 10 ton estimate came specifically from that scene. Not the scene before or after.

quote:

If the boulder appeared to be solid rock then there is no way I would put its weight that low.

quote:

So I thought the boulder was actually made of feathers and foam? Really?

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
IOW, you picked the part where the boulder looked the smallest to you in order to lowball the feat. even though you knew the entire boulder was shown both before and after those few seconds to be much larger.

Basically, you just admitted to trolling.



You're the only one that thinks it looked "light-weight" and to be honest, you're massively biased.




It fits your argument.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by h1a8
I didn't remember the scene before Tbh. I re-watched it and realized it was there before he struck it.

quote:

I disagree. I believe most of you feel that the Boulder appears softer than real rock and the special effects was mediocre.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
Only you continued to use the same argument even after you posted a video clip showing that the boulder was quite large. Nobody is buying your faulty memory excuse, you purposely ignored the parts of your own clip that proved how large the boulder was.

The common term for your actions is trolling.



Well, you're wrong. You are the only one that holds that opinion, but feel free to prove me wrong by giving me the names of the posters that agree with you.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by h1a8
What are you talking about? I posted the clip AFTER my mind was already made up. I just used the clip to show everyone that the size of the boulder changed.

Doesn't matter as only an idiot would think it appears to be solid rock. Forgive me for thinking that most here aren't idiots.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
Only you weren't honest, the very clip you posted proves the boulder was far larger than your claim. As for your massively biased opinion in regards to its weight. Prove it.

Edit: by the way did anyone else notice how he said it's my fault that he doesn't accept the 150 to 200 ton weight anymore. In other words, he just admitted that he doesn't base his opinions on facts he bases them on emotion.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
Of course you were trying to lie, otherwise you would have admitted you were wrong when you posted the clip that literally proved you wrong.

No, you got all butt-hurt and decided to throw out facts in favor of your emotion based opinion.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Silent Master
Has anyone else noticed H1's massive double standard? in that he is using what he thinks the boulder looks like after Kurse damaged it as the basis for saying it's not solid. Whereas in the Bane thread he complained that we used what the column looked like after it was damaged.