Premise from round 1: Everyone is familiar with Ant's semi-tournament we held many months ago that turned out dead in the end because Ant didn't want to do Revan/Vader placement before the end of the debate. While I understand the sentiment, I think it's the time to give this thing a new run either way, especially since Az vs. Ant in the CV takes so long, people could really make up their minds based on what we saw there.
THE RULES
• Legends only. Canon material doesn't count at all.
• We rate the candidates as in character.
• No entity-like characters are ranked - I list them in the end. Characters like post-pool Taalon are allowed, as well as Dathomir Talzin.
• No collectives are ranked - Dread Masters and similar are out.
• This is about actual, direct combat and the overall prowess. Not the best swordsman, not the best Force user, just the one that can beat the others. No matter how - sabers, hand to hand or the Force.
VOTING PROCESS
• Everybody writes his choice in a post. We start from #1, then #2, etc. There are 7 days to vote.
• After the votes are summarized, I shall post the vote-count, and allow people 2 days to change their opinion, sort of round 2 (so if you have both UnuThul and Nyax as > Yoda, but Yoda got 10 votes, Unu 8, and Nyax 4, you can change the vote to UnuThul to reflect this).
• The idea is to get top 10. If there will be will to continue the ranking after that, why not, but so far, let's stick to top 10.
• No polls because of socks.
Banned characters: The Ones, Abeloth, Bedlam Spirits, Force Demons, Force Priestesses, Terror from Beyond, World Razer, Zakuul Gods, Zonama Sekot, Yuuzhan'tar and other "entity-like" if I didn't list them here.
If you must know, Darth Bane sheltered himself from every single droplet of rain sent his way by a rainstorm for several minutes, using not an umbrella, but rather his own lightsaber.
You would do well to back up this assertion with a citation of evidence. If you can convince me Tulak Hord is deserving of the #2 spot, I will submit to your greater authority on this matter.
Oct 22nd, 2018 01:09 AM
