KMC Forums - Beast vs Punisher

quote: (post)
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
No.

In the Red Zone, Creed was already taxed from fighting other guys and he still beat Hank.

Sabes literally one shot Hank...

quote: (post)
Originally posted by carver9
I dont know why people dont mention Beast stomping Frenzy...

https://m.imgur.com/a/XcDkx

Because it was from an era where Beast had an upgrade that's been dropped by Marvel. It's not really relevant, unless you're writing Dareangel fanfiction.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by carver9
The first fight was a stalemate obvious with both ready to end it.

It's not a stalemate if Wolverine's attack will kill Beast, and Beast's attack won't do shit to Wolverine.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by carver9
Beast did extremely well against both Wolverine (who complimented Beast speed) AND Sabertooth. He outright stomped Spiral who is leagues above Punisher and she also had weapons. A serious Beast would rape Punisher.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by StyleTime

Sabretooth had just fought Caliban, Cyclops, and Iceman. He was on the run after months of imprisonment at the X-Mansion. He escaped to a train where Beast ambushed him, and Sabretooth, in one hit, still had Beast dead to rights before Cyclops returned to save Beast's ass. Beast later fought Sabretooth with a group and still got saved by Jean once Sabretooth started to fight back.

As for Spiral, he ambushed her while she was unaware and still failed to KO her. When the situation was reversed later, Spiral one-shot Beast.

The one valid win here is Danger. Whedon liked his Beast more competent than most, so he did get that feat. However, it's 1 victory from 10-12 years ago. Before that, you'd have to go back to basically the X-Factor days, with an upgrade that no longer applies, for consistent feats from Beast. If we're having to dig like that for wins, then maybe it's time to admit he ain't all that?

Beast's performances just plain don't sync up with his paper stats.