Aside from the fact that the writer also made multiple tweets state that it isn't canon(to both companies) and you can't set a winner for them due to they don't share canon
I wouldn’t put it like that. Lol but there are segments of fandom that are both super passionate and sometimes rigid in their point of view. Makes little sense to argue about power levels or make comparisons between IPs that don’t share canon. It’s all subjective.
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998 Didn't the writer also state that Godzilla's atomic breath just happened to have kryptonite-like radiation? (please log in to view the image) https://twitter.com/BrianBooch/stat...684449444442486
Aside from the fact that the writer also made multiple tweets state that it isn't canon(to both companies) and you can't set a winner for them due to they don't share canon
So after being exposured to kryptonite for an extended period of time. Batman feels Superman's heart needs a teravolt(trillion volts) burst to restart his heart.
Superman later recovers without outside help https://ibb.co/SrG41vh https://ibb.co/5vtFJRR https://ibb.co/jWg1mL1
Canon simply means that it will be part of the story moving forward. Which we knew wouldn't be the case, due to intellectual property rights.
But what's noteworthy is that Superman (and the kaiju, supposedly?) are written to be as powerful as they are in the mainline continuity. Which means that Superman, Captain Marvel, and an enraged Supergirl aren't physically strong enough to subdue a kaiju, or at the very least not Godzilla. Even King Kong didn't lose his footing after Kara socked him.
Originally posted by Astner Canon simply means that it will be part of the story moving forward. Which we knew wouldn't be the case, due to intellectual property rights.
But what's noteworthy is that Superman (and the kaiju, supposedly?) are written to be as powerful as they are in the mainline continuity. Which means that Superman, Captain Marvel, and an enraged Supergirl aren't physically strong enough to subdue a kaiju, or at the very least not Godzilla. Even King Kong didn't lose his footing after Kara socked him.
So if we go by writer's tweets, Superman is the strongest in the DCU?
Edit:
Plus, if we really take the writer's tweets at face value. The writer also states comparing the two IPs' powerlevels wouldn't work, since they don't share canon. So I'm not sure you can scale their powerlevels based on this series.
The property DC has is, though, Superman's IP.
Last edited by qwertyuiop1998 on Dec 27th, 2023 at 12:47 AM
At the end of the day it's just an opinion about a character he wasn't writing (ie, mainstream Superman). He says "the Superman I'm writing is just as strong as that Superman" but since he isn't writing the latter, it's about as relevant as Kirkman's opinion on how Invincible chars would stack up against other superheroes.
Which is presumably why he also tweeted "Makes little sense to argue about power levels or make comparisons between IPs that don’t share canon. It’s all subjective."
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998 So if we go by writer's tweets, Superman is the strongest in the DCU?
Sure, but it's a bit too nondescript.
The point isn't to paint this as something that can be projected onto canon. But more so a case study of how a writer perceives the power of the characters in the story he writes.
Originally posted by Astner
The point isn't to paint this as something that can be projected onto canon. But more so a case study of how a writer perceives the power of the characters in the stories they write.
Yeah, so I think that's why we usually wouldn't use tweets to substitute for on panel proofs/feats here. Since not all of their opinions can be made in canon
Originally posted by Astner Canon simply means that it will be part of the story moving forward. Which we knew wouldn't be the case, due to intellectual property rights.
But what's noteworthy is that Superman (and the kaiju, supposedly?) are written to be as powerful as they are in the mainline continuity. Which means that Superman, Captain Marvel, and an enraged Supergirl aren't physically strong enough to subdue a kaiju, or at the very least not Godzilla. Even King Kong didn't lose his footing after Kara socked him.