Don't believe everything you read. Obviously there was some pretty rotten ideas posted. (You may say that there is no such thing as a bad idea, but if you think that then...well, lets just say I dished out all my shame on you's.) I just noticed you are online.
yeah i noticed you contridicting other people alot, no offence, anyway some of the stuff on there was pure nonsence, but tring to somehow incoperate everyones idea
Incorporate eh? (What, am I...Canadian now? And what's with all the parenthesis lately? I dunno...and I'm talking to myself. Hmm.) Ya see, I don't usually bother it incorporate other people's ideas because normally I try to contradict them whether or not I agree with them. It causes people to...dare I say it...think. Its a lot of fun to argue. I have my own opinions, but I posted them so far back. Must I do it again?
Nazgul, I like your thought of Sirius being able to come back when Harry really needs him... But I'm not sure if I should believe it... Anyway, Sirius being between life and death is something I also thought of...Well done ;-)
What my point was is J.k rowling didn't say harry picked up the mirror after he broke it, it just said he smashed it so i was saying i dont think j.k would say in a later book that he DID pick it up And yea we are arguing about harry potter but i happen to find it very offensive when people write bad comments on my grammer and spelling.
__________________ Draco: Your dead potter!
Harry: Funny you'ld think i'ld have stopped walking
No no no. I never yell. As a matter of fact, I have found that I seem to be the only one who isn't offended at every little that is posted. Anyway...LUNA: You say that its not JK's style to write about something that happened in previous matters...but that's basically a whole part of the story where she writes and clarifies things that have happened in the past. So I think it would very well work if she came back to clarify what happened witht he mirror. Harry didn't necessarily have to have it...maybe it was picked up by someone else. Perhaps the house elves cleaned it up, and Dobby saved it for Harry. (Not saying it happened, its just a possibility.) Anyway...That's what I think. I think that its contradicting when you say its not JK's style to go back and what happened previously...when she does it all the time.
Gender: Male Location: Huntington Beach, California
I wanna know how people become ghosts. I'm sure Sirus won't come back as a ghost, but it would be cool if he became a hogwarts ghost and bugged the crap outta Snape all day long. I think Sirus is long gone, but i agree with the general populous about harry being able to find a means of communicating with Sirus.
That's a good question about how people become ghosts. (From previous threads, these are some of what people think The people wanted to die. Like with Moaning Mrytle, she was miserable, and Nearly Headless Nick might have wanted to die as well. (I personally don't agree with that...but who knows, right?) Also, some people say that they didn't want to die. See examples above. I think this one might be possible, because the people weren't ready to go into the next life. The last one (one that I DO NOT think is possible) is because they were murdered. Or...because they didn't die a natural death. But that means that Harry's parents would be wandering around, but then other's counter that they came out of Voldy's wand....but then I must say that's because there was a magical flaw and only a very special case. Well, there ya go. I think that there are many reasons but no one is really going to get it right until JK tells us for sure.
yes i carried it on after ur post which was posted the same minute of mine . Nick made it sound that people choose if they become a ghost or not but he said not many people choose it. I think mabey when you become a ghost you have to stay one forever which i personaly wouldn't like. But nick said he was scared of death and mrytle wanted to come back and torment the girl who had been picking on her. Perhaps winky picked up the mirror and has been talking to sirius ever since lol.. that would be funny.
__________________ Draco: Your dead potter!
Harry: Funny you'ld think i'ld have stopped walking
That would be interesting. WHo nows, perhaps you;d have to want to come back to be a ghost. There could be little clues here or there that are going to seem really obvious once we find out.
KMC Community Forums
Nov 29th, 2003 02:34 AM
The people wanted to die. Like with Moaning Mrytle, she was miserable, and Nearly Headless Nick might have wanted to die as well. (I personally don't agree with that...but who knows, right?) Also, some people say that they didn't want to die. See examples above. I think this one might be possible, because the people weren't ready to go into the next life. The last one (one that I DO NOT think is possible) is because they were murdered. Or...because they didn't die a natural death. But that means that Harry's parents would be wandering around, but then other's counter that they came out of Voldy's wand....but then I must say that's because there was a magical flaw and only a very special case. Well, there ya go. I think that there are many reasons but no one is really going to get it right until JK tells us for sure.
. Nick made it sound that people choose if they become a ghost or not but he said not many people choose it. I think mabey when you become a ghost you have to stay one forever which i personaly wouldn't like. But nick said he was scared of death and mrytle wanted to come back and torment the girl who had been picking on her. Perhaps winky picked up the mirror and has been talking to sirius ever since lol.. that would be funny.
