I have that book also, and I don't remember seeing any veiled creature...but prehaps you caught something that I didn't. As for the Sirius theroies...the only one that I actually disagree with is the fact that he left with Buckbeak. (Yeah, I have heard saying that he disapparated before her fell and then he an Buckbeak ran away...DON'T ask.) Anyway, I think that Sirius will be back, and that veil is going to really play a part. PLUS, the room that was ALWAYS to remained locked. I know that Harry is going to open it to find out just what magic his mom left in him.
Gender: Female Location: in a double decker bus...
i dont know if jk will think of a way to bring him back, but when she wrote it, it WAS a death, cos she said in an interview acoupla weeks b4 OotP came out, that she cried after she wrote the death
i dont think he will come back ( wtch is sad cuz i like sirius) but we all knew someone was gunna die and just because it was someone we liked doesnt mean he will come back (but he could! )
__________________
Go bannana its your birthday!
Go bannana its your birthday!
Now i must go... vanish!
1cek0ol> That is also my sentiment. That the Order is using the situation. They know how attached Harry is to Sirius, and it was this attachment that Voldemort abused to lure Harry to the Department of Mysteries.
If the arch-way is a portal to some kind of afterlife, or another dimension or other mysterious space, then perhaps Sirius is dead, but he may still be able to contact Harry – perhaps through the mirror. We’ll just have to wait and see.
__________________ "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities."
-Voltaire
"That includes ruining Halloween because someone swallowed a Bible."
"I just thought you were a guy."
"... Most guys do."
I know you just didnt tell me what to do, i can say all the shit i want to. i can tell people to **** off if i want to. so keep your mouth shut you uptight BIATCH
whoa... so what if i'm a kid at heart, some people are just old bags at heart like you lee^. God! and let me guest yur what 3... no wait a three year old would admit to being an Ass..so you must be 234 and dead...
ummm i have a theory bout harry seeing sirius again what if he uses the mirror he used in the first book that might work if he really is dead and harry really wants to see him however in the book i think it is true that the order didnt really show much remorse after sirius death maybe they are jus trying to protect harry
Sirius may be dead...but I wish that people would stick to subjects in this forum. Sirius most likely will come back, otherwise Rowling wouldn't have put that mirror in for no reason. Of course, it could just be there to show what might have been. However, I don't doubt that Sirius will contact Harry somehow. Anyway, I think that the OotP was actually very beaten up over the loss of Sirius, I mean, he WAS Lupin's last remaining friend from the school-group. I think that perhaps it just didn't hit them as hard because it WAS Harry's fault. I don't think Dumbledore should have to blame himself as his acts were pure. But...does anyone argee that Harry is just being a little butt-head to everyone!? He got SO jealous of Ron when he was named Prefect, but when Ron got mad at him back in the 4th book, Harry couldn't understand why. Ron didn't ask to be a Prefect no more than Harry asked to be in the Tournament. Harry is really starting to be disliked by me, and I blame him for Sirius' death. Harsh...yes. Wrong...not really. If he would have only done what Dumbledore told him to, and if he hadn't of been such a nosy little jerk then he never would have looked in Snape's past, thus still having the Occlumency lesson. (Yes, I know this is long, just bear it with me.) Plus, I don't know what's going on, but I think that J.K left a few hints about Harry and Hermione's little relationship too. Of course, there is always Krum..but ya never know. I just expect Harry to be meaner and meaner and then he will only hurt more people than he saves.
umm can i jus say u said to stick to the subject yet u mention harrys and hermiones relationship take ur own advice there are more than enough threads on that however u make some valid points and i feel the same way about harry he was moody in the last book
rosebloom- i agree its not all dumbledores fault harry takes some but if you saw you mom or best friend or the person you love most being tourtered to death you cant blame harry for being rash in tring to save his life!
__________________
Go bannana its your birthday!
Go bannana its your birthday!
Now i must go... vanish!
i think the same thing and from the other books we learned that harry is rash and heroic and thats one of the reasons we love him and id probably do the same thing but id get adults first
KMC Community Forums
Aug 9th, 2003 07:40 PM
)
vanish!
however in the book i think it is true that the order didnt really show much remorse after sirius death 
maybe they are jus trying to protect harry
take ur own advice there are more than enough threads on that however u make some valid points and i feel the same way about harry he was moody in the last book 
and id probably do the same thing but id get adults first 
