O Review
by Christopher Null (cnull AT mindspring DOT com)August 20th, 2001
O
A film review by Christopher Null
Copyright 2001 filmcritic.com
Well, all good classics eventually come to a crashing end (Planet of the
Apes, anyone?), and the works of Shakespeare are no exception. This
time out, it's Othello that gets an urban/teen makeover -- and
considering that Slick Willy's themes about the hazards of interracial
relationships are still present after 400 years, you'd think O would be
a gimme. No such luck.
With this updating, Othello and Desdemona have become Odin and Desi.
Odin (Mekhi Phifer) is the sole black student at a ritzy prep school for
the overly wealthy. He's also the star basketball player, destined for
greatness in college ball, at least. He carries on a semi-secret love
affair with Desi (Julia Stiles), a waifish Julia Stiles stock character,
who is also the daughter of the dean (John Heard). The basketball coach
(Martin Sheen) favors his star player, of course, virtually ignoring his
own son Hugo (Josh Hartnett, in the famed and villainous Iago role), who
even turns to steroids (gasp!) to improve his performance in an attempt
to match Odin's court prowess. After years of no luck and less love,
Hugo eventually masterminds a plan to disgrace Odin... all of which ends
disastrously, as you know if you've ever read the play.
Unfortunately, while the real Othello spins a web of rage, misplaced
trust, and betrayal, O portrays its characters as snotty brats who
suffer through daily temper tantrums. Romeo and Juliet works in the
teen genre because it's about teens. Othello is about adults with adult
problems, namely a Moor suffering from a lifetime of persecution (and a
poor choice of friends). O's Odin has just about everything he could
ask for, despite having grown up "in the hood." Both Phifer and his
character simply have no life experience to justify Odin's actions
(Phifer's crucial experience in MTV's Carmen: A Hip Hopera
notwithstanding). When the murderous finale eventually rolls around, it
doesn't play as remotely believable.
Also, despite a 91 minute running time, the film drags. It takes at
least half an hour to establish a) that Odin is a great basketball
player, b) that he is in love with Desi, and c) that Hugo is pissed
about a and b. The remainder of the movie is better paced, but not a
lot.
From a technical standpoint, O is a much bigger mess. Directed by O
Brother, Where Art Thou? actor Tim Blake Nelson, who has directed some
creepy stuff in the past, including 1997's Eye of God, the film's
biggest flaw is an abrupt, almost bad, editing job -- coming in to
scenes too late and leaving too soon, and vice versa. The constant rap
music soundtrack is appealing at first but becomes a grating noise after
the halfway mark. And in the final act, details are garbled,
glossed-over, or just plain wrong, all this despite Hugo's promise that
he has considered every option in his "master plan."
None of this is meant to say that O is a total waste of time. At the
very least, it's a far better film than the obtuse 1995 version of
Othello, which starred Lawrence Fishburne and strayed far from the
original tale but still relied on cryptic Elizabethan-era English. O is
far more faithful to the original story than I would have suspected,
even handling those tricky asides and character-hiding-in-a-closet
scenes with aplomb. Ultimately, the source material keeps O mostly
afloat, telling a unique and tragic story about how a single,
well-placed rumor can ruin the life of somebody who otherwise has it
made.
Mired in the "marketing violent movies to teens is bad" controversy of
1999-2000, O has been sitting on the shelf for a while, building a large
volume of clips that claim it's the most violent thing since Natural
Born Killers. A word to audiences -- this is far from the truth. In
fact, those expecting a Columbine-style rampage (a ridiculous link which
I've nonetheless found in 538 articles on Nexis.com) will be
disappointed by the relatively tame ending -- comprising four gunshots
and a quiet strangling.
RATING: ***
|------------------------------|
\ ***** Perfection \
\ **** Good, memorable film \
\ *** Average, hits and misses \
\ ** Sub-par on many levels \
\ * Unquestionably awful \
|------------------------------|
MPAA Rating: R
Director: Tim Blake Nelson
Producer: Daniel Fried, Eric Gitter, Anthony Rhulen
Writer: Brad Kaaya
Starring: Mekhi Phifer, Josh Hartnett, Julia Stiles, Martin Sheen, Elden
Henson, Andrew Keegan, Rain Phoenix, John Heard, Rachel Schumate,
Christopher Jones
http://www.lionsgate-ent.com/dnm/profile.html?pid=IN-L-00046
---
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/redirect?tag=filmcriticcom&path=subst/video/sellers/amazon-top-100-dvd.html Movie Fiends: Check out Amazon.com's Top 100 Hot DVDs!
Visit filmcritic.com on the Web at http://www.filmcritic.com
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
