One True Thing Review
by Walter Frith (wfrith AT cgocable DOT net)March 19th, 1999
'One True Thing' (1998)
A movie review by Walter Frith
[email protected]
Member of the ‘Online Film Critics Society’
http://ofcs.org/ofcs/
Set in the mid to late 80's, a film like 'One True Thing' attempts to tell the story of Kate Gulden (Meryl Streep) who has dedicated her life to being a homemaker and in the process of taking care of her family, finds that she becomes an unintentional burden to them when for once, she needs taking care of after she develops a slow and torturing form of cancer. Did I mention that this story line is only a sub plot? What the film is really about is a re-examination of priorities from the stand point of the woman's daughter Ellen (Renee Zellweger) and how her career driven life as a Harvard educated writer comes to a sudden halt when she seems to be the only one in a position to give her mother the care she needs while she dies slowly at home after being bed ridden and confined to a wheel chair for too long.
Meryl Streep receives first billing in this movie and received an Oscar nomination for it as Best Actress but her role is clearly a supporting one. Zellweger is the film's protagonist --- a hard and judgmental woman who can't cook, clean or do anything in that capacity as well as her mother. She carries a secret resentment from not having anything in common with mom and somehow feels that she is totally blameless. Her father (William Hurt) is a fellow writer who runs a department at a post secondary educational institute and while she has plenty in common with him from a writer's stand point, she can't quite embrace her father's generation and grows further and furthr away from him when she finds he has been having affairs while his wife is dying.
What makes this film work is that although the story is told in flashback from the the daughter's point of view, we don't really know until the end of the film, who it is she's talking to about the film's situations. Combining that with top notch performances and an easy flowing sense of style, 'One True Thing' does pay off and is especially important to film audiences that can identify with its subject matter. It does have a distant and rather cold feeling about it that keeps it from being a true motion picture classic but you have to admire it for wanting to escape the trappings of a weepy and pretentious tear jerker, and become just another inflatable film full of false emotion.
The film transcends any thought of making either the career woman or the homemaker the heroine and treats them both as equals. Quite a remarkable thing in the age where most woman are in the work place and rightfully so because in many cases it's out of necessity, and where the homemaker is often viewed by many as wasting her life. But 'One True Thing' shows us that as long as one feels their existence is important and they perform a valuable service that nothing ever goes to waste.
The balancing act this movie performs once again fails in the category of under written characters. William Hurt's portrayal of the father and Tom Everett Scott, who plays the family son and Zellweger's brother, are both not used to their full potential and are rather forgettable characters. The film is also too lengthy for many attention spans but if you can stick it out for two plus hours, it is a film that not only tells the story of a family but in many ways it looks around for exactly what the definition of a family really is.
OUT OF 5 > * * * 1/2
Visit FILM FOLLOW-UP by Walter Frith
http://www.cgocable.net/~wfrith/movies.htm
-----------------------------------------------------------------
* * * * * - a must see
* * * * 1/2 - don't miss it
* * * * - an excellent film
* * * 1/2 - a marginal recommendation
* * * - can't quite recommend it
* * 1/2 - don't recommend it
* * - avoid it
* 1/2 - avoid it seriously
* - avoid it AT ALL COSTS
1/2 - see it at your own risk
zero - may be hazardous to your health
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
