The Road to Perdition Review

by Joshua Tyler (tyler AT filmcritic DOT com)
July 9th, 2002
ROAD TO PERDITION

A film review by Joshua Tyler

Copyright 2002 filmcritic.com

Murder is a cold and senseless act. Those who make it their life must by necessity be hard and brutal men. Road to Perdition never flinches away from that, but somehow, in the emotionally empty lives of mafia killers, finds warmth, depth, and soul.

This second film from American Beauty director Sam Mendes presents a highly stylized and muddied look into the world of the Irish mob. Michael Sullivan (Tom Hanks) is at the center of it, as mob boss John Rooney’s (Paul Newman) personal “Angel of Death.” Raised as Rooney’s son, Sullivan and his family have been given an idyllic life, marred only by the secrecy of Sullivan’s dastardly work. But when his oldest son Michael Jr. (Tyler Hoechlin) witnesses dad taking care of business, their world is shattered, as mob boss Rooney’s overeager son murders Sullivan’s wife and youngest child in response. Now, Sullivan must put his loyalty to the test to protect his oldest son Michael and buy a life for them both.

Road to Perdition is not some parody of the Irish or Italian mafia, populated with clichéd characters uttering predictably gangsteresque quips about “the family.” Rather, it's a blurring of the lines between right and wrong, a beautiful and layered look into the heart of a man who commits murder yet really does know the difference between good and evil. Hanks’ character is no hero, though he could have been played as such, had Mendes allowed it. But we’re never permitted to stop and attempt to rationalize his misdeeds with platitudes of necessity. Instead, Perdition keeps reminding us that the man whom we would cast in the role of a saint is cold, ruthless, and without remorse.

It’s Hanks that makes it work. His Sullivan is dark, silent, and immovable. Hanks' natural likeability could have made bringing that sensibility to life difficult, but he uses his honest and genuine persona to keep the lines of good and evil blurred throughout the film. He’s subtle. Every expression has a meaning, every grimace tells a tale. He’s smart, calculating, and cool. Sullivan is cold yet never cruel: Honest, loyal, caring, but willing and ready to kill.

This dark and rainy film wastes nothing on its quest of exploration and redemption. There is no scene, no role without purpose. Even a random hitman (in this case played by Jude Law) though he says little and appears only to bring death, becomes a real living and breathing person complete with motivation, personality, and depth. Law like no other has an uncanny ability to completely inhabit his character, even adopting mannerisms, speech patterns, and movements that might seem inconsequential, but when added together create a flesh-and-blood individual behind the trigger.

Newman too draws all there is to get out of his character, a dismal and evil man who somehow seems dashing and grandfatherly in his veteran acting hands. Winding his way throughout the story much like the film’s haunting score, Newman’s John Rooney walks a path towards inevitability, unwilling or unable to stop the wheels his devilish son has already set in motion.

Soaked in rain, snow, and beautifully framed shots of an interminably gray world, Road to Perdition avoids the simplistic and easy sidetracks taken by so many other modern films. Mendes stays the course and keeps us questioning the morality of the man. Using sound, light, and shadow, he develops a story layered unlike any other, while bullets rip with alternately shocking explosiveness and utter silence across the screen.

Part coming-of-age story, part tragedy, where Perdition best succeeds is by reaching in and grabbing straight to the heart of Sullivan and his son. Road to Perdition soars above all possible expectations to deliver a weighty, thoughtful, and brazenly creative film anchored by Oscar caliber performances from everyone involved.

RATING: ***** [HIGHEST RATING]

[* = lowest rating / ***** = highest rating]

MPAA Rating: R

Director: Sam Mendes

Producer: Sam Mendes, Dean Zanuck, Richard D. Zanuck

Writer: David Self

Starring: Tom Hanks, Paul Newman, Tyler Hoechlin, Jude Law, Daniel Craig, Stanley Tucci, Jennifer Jason Leigh

http://www.roadtoperdition.com/

---
filmcritic.com / http://filmcritic.com/

More on 'The Road to Perdition'...

---

Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.