Seven Pounds Review
by Homer Yen (homeryen88 AT gmail DOT com)December 26th, 2008
"Seven Pounds" - A Bit Too Heavy
by Homer Yen
(c) 2008
In an early scene, Ben Thomas (Will Smith) says in an angelic voice, "I have the power to make a dramatic difference in a person's life." No, he doesn't possess supernatural powers nor does he hold sway with people at high levels to purvey special favors nor is he incredibly wealthy. He's just a well-meaning guy who has a gift (several, actually) to give, much like Forrest Gump who could bring something special to the people around him. And, that's a great message to send during the Christmas season. Because, we all have the power to help others and to make another person's life better.
You may have seen a film that he did two Christmases ago entitled "The Pursuit of Happyness". That theme dealt with redemption, which also runs throughout "Seven Pounds." However, while that film had an easy-to-follow arc, this film's arc is oblique and the main character's motivation isn't so transparent for 80% of the film. A series of flashbacks give us a glimpse into his life several years back. He seemed happier as if every gift that he had ever wanted had been bestowed upon him. But, some thing has happened, which we aren't immediately privy to. Now, he's terribly sad. He has asked his best friend (Barry Pepper) to carry out a strange favor. So strange is it that his best friend doesn't even know if he can bring himself to carrying out that request.
For the first three-quarters of the film, the audience has more and more questions than the film is willing to reveal. Is Ben a messiah? Is he a liar? What's his purpose here? What the heck does the title of the film mean? All we can discern is that Ben has formulated some kind of plan and that he is intent on carrying out.
We pick up bits and pieces as there are all sorts of people that Ben interacts with.
There's a blind musician. There's a small boy going through chemotherapy. There's a kindly social worker. What links them and Ben together? If you're patient enough, you will find out. Most of the screen time is focused on his budding romance with Emily (Rosario Dawson), who is also suffering some kind of medical ailment. There is a compassionate love story that emerges here. Neither at first seems to have a reason to really live. Yet, when together, their love for each other is the reason that they both want to carry on. Their relationship is tender and both bring to their roles a nice range of acting skills and good chemistry to make this one of the nicest on-screen romances this year.
Yet, by now, I'm sure that you can detect my lack of enthusiasm. Will Smith has had an impressive run, scoring 8 consecutive $100 million hits. Despite his nice performance in this film, that record may stop here. It's not that this is a bad film. In fact, sometimes a film is more interesting when a person's motives are kept secret until the very end, which is the case here. But when there isn't anything to latch onto, it's like being in a raft out at sea and just letting the currents take you where they may. Some kind of hint beyond the quick-cut flashbacks would've been nice. You've heard the saying: the mind can only absorb what the butt can endure. Perhaps "Five Pounds" instead of seven would've been better.
Grade: B-
S: 1 out of 3
L: 0 out of 3
V: 2 out of 3
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
