Simon Birch Reviews

Simon Birch Review
by Luke Buckmaster
SIMON BIRCH Cast: Joseph Mazzello, Ian Michael Smith, Ashley Judd, Oliver Platt, David Strathairn, Dana Ivey, Jan Hooks, Jim Carrey Director: Mark Steven Johnson Screenplay: Mark Steven Johnson suggested by "A Prayer for Owen Meany" by John...more

Simon Birch Review
by Luke Buckmaster
SIMON BIRCH Cast: Joseph Mazzello, Ian Michael Smith, Ashley Judd, Oliver Platt, David Strathairn, Dana Ivey, Jan Hooks, Jim Carrey Director: Mark Steven Johnson Screenplay: Mark Steven Johnson suggested by "A Prayer for Owen Meany" by John...more

Simon Birch Review
by Greg King
SIMON BIRCH (PG). (Hollywood Pictures/Buena Vista International) Director: Mark Steven Johnson Stars: Joseph Mazzello, Ian Mitchell Smith, Oliver Platt, David Starthairn, Jan Hooks, Ashley Judd, Jim Carrey, Dana Ivey Running time: 110 minutes. Last...more

Simon Birch Review
by jksalisbury AT my-dejanews DOT com
I looked back this week, at some of the reviews that I've written lately, and I noticed a theme. I had something bad to say about most of them (save Return To Paradise), and it caused me think. Am I really to hard and critical on movies, have I become...more

Simon Birch Review
by Edwin Jahiel
SIMON BIRCH ** 1/2 Directed and written by Mark Steven Johnson, suggested by the novel ³A Prayer for Owen Meany² by John Irving.Photography, Aaron E. Schneider. Editing, Betsy Heimann. Production design, David Chapman. Music, Marc Shaiman. Cast: Ian...more

Simon Birch Review
by Mark O'Hara
I've yet to decide if a movie is good if it makes you cry. SIMON BIRCH gave me at least one all-out belly laugh, during the Christmas pageant, and I've thought for some time that a movie is decent if it makes you shout in laughter. But crying? more

Simon Birch Review
by Matt Williams
Simon Birch is a film loosely based on John Irving's novel, A Prayer for Owen Meany. Names, dates, plot elements and places have been changed...so fans of the books should be wary going in. It may not be a faithful adaptation, but with an open mind,...more

Simon Birch Review
by Ryan Davis
I saw Simon Birch in a basically sold out theater, on a Sunday afternoon. When the movie was over and the audience was exiting, I didn’t hear one negative comment, and I didn’t have any to offer. more

Simon Birch Review
by Craig Roush
Release Date: September 11, 1998 Starring: Ian Michael Smith, Joseph Mazzello, Ashley Judd, Oliver Platt, David Strathairn, Dana Ivey, Jim Carrey Directed by: Mark Steven Johnson Distributed by: Buena Vista Pictures MPAA Rating: PG (language, emotional...more

Simon Birch Review
by Curtis Edmonds
Movies cheat, everyone knows that. There's a whole industry dedicated to special effects, the smoke and mirrors filmmakers need to create whatever illusions they need to tell their story. However, we've gotten so used to looking at the visual effects...more

Simon Birch Review
by Walter Frith
"They don't make 'em like that anymore!" That's what the true movie fan will say and only a true cynic who is angry at the world, blaming it for all of their personal failures will hate this film as it is nearly impossible to truly dislike a film like...more
Simon Birch Review
by Joe Barlow
STARRING: Ian Michael Smith, Joseph Mazzello, Ashley Judd, Oliver Platt, Jan Hooks, Jim Carrey DIRECTOR: Mark Steven Johnson WRITER: Mark Steven Johnson RATED: PG-13 (profanity) YEAR: 1998 SEEN AT: Waverly Place, Cary...more
Simon Birch Review
by Michael Redman
Oddly enough, even in these cynical times, we are a nation of believers. Everything's going to get better. A better life is just around the corner. Although the programmers working on it say that it's impossible, we believe that the Y2K bug will be fixed...more
Simon Birch Review
by Michael Dequina
Aside from the fleeting presences of big screen talent such as Ashley Judd and Jim Carrey, there's little in this modest, engaging, yet cloying drama to distinguish it from, as my guest at the screening said, "a _Hallmark_Hall_of_Fame_ movie."...more
Simon Birch Review
by Edward Johnson-ott
Simon Birch (1998) Joseph Mazzello, Ian Michael Smith, Ashley Judd, Oliver Platt, David Strathairn, Dana Ivey, Jan Hooks, Jim Carrey. Music by Marc Shaiman. Screenplay by Mark Steven Johnson (suggested by John Irving's "A Prayer for Owen Meany")....more
Simon Birch Review
by Scott Renshaw
SIMON BIRCH (Touchstone) Starring: Joseph Mazzello, Ian Michael Smith, Oliver Platt, David Strathairn, Ashley Judd, Jan Hooks. Screenplay: Mark Steven Johnson, suggested by the novel _A Prayer for Owen Meany_ by John Irving. Producers: Laurence Mark...more
Simon Birch Review
by D Lewis
SIMON BIRCH Reviewed by Dennis Lewis If you had to dab away a few tears at the conclusion of "Titanic," you may want to take along a full box of Puffs if you go see "Simon Birch." "Simon...more
Simon Birch Review
by David Butterworth
A cinematic version of one of John Irving's novels is always cause for celebration even if, as in the case of "Simon Birch," the treatment is merely "suggested by," rather than strictly based on, the book. more