Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

In one line- "I.....am........a..........JEDI"

That was great. His other lines were dull because bad things had just happened. Do you really want him to say all of his lines with power....cause thats overacting. That one line is great!

was that his real voice?

No it was Frank Oz impersonating him.

ah! I thought I recognized it

Is it Anakin who says "they attacked at dawn"?

That's Lars, surely.

talking about Shmi very lickly

Which Lars? It doesn't sound like Joel Edgerton (Owen). His voice isn't as deep as that. Unless Lucas lowered it like he did with Amidala.

Clieg is another possibility...
well the older one it is I guess

I'd say it is Cliegg.

i bet its wicket

Beetchawawa!!!

Who's Cliegg?

Clieg Lars is the one that marries Shmi in EpII...

And Owen is his brother, I take it?

I think, not sure now, don't think it's his son...

its his son.

thanx...
that makes that there are a lot of years between EpII and IV...

yeah, im not sure but i think between EpII and EpIII its bout 10 years. and between EpIII and EpIV its 20.. not sure tho..

RC will know

well; I thought that between EpI and EpIV there was 30 years ...

Nope, his son. Ergo, Anakin's stepbrother, ergo, Luke's uncle.

Ergo? No.

yerssot, that's what I heard too, 30 years between I and IV. But look how old Kenobi is in IV. It would make more sense if it were 40+ years between I and IV

Sadly with Luke and Leia at 18 in ANH, and Anakin 10 years older in AOTC than he was in TPM, it is DAMN hard for it to be anything more than 30 years.

Well, Lucas blew that one, because Kenobi was older than 55 in ANH. My dad is almost 50, and he looks a lot better than he did.

Well, that's the way it is, To. Obi-Wan was originally envisaged as older in TPM, but in the end he wasn't.

The numbers I quote stand. Obi-Wan's looks will just have to be a matter of suspension of disbelief.

Besides, he was very stressed...

Put that one in the plot flaw column

who the hell is ergo

(and no hell is not a bad word)

what if i said-


who the heaven is ergo...

thank you...DONT respond to that- respond to the first question

Just behind C3-P0s memory, eh? Because it is still uncertain if that one will be explained...

Quit that. what' with this damned attitude here? Ush, are you stirring up trouble with the new guys?

I have no idea.

Ergo isn't anyone, d8. It means 'therefore'.

What's wrong with Obi-Wan in ANH? He has white hair and that's all. It's not like he was a wrinkly old man.

well, he is wrinkeled and old though...

Yeah, he's pretty old.

But not "Palpatine" old. I don't find it that hard to beleive that he is 55 in ANH.

well, he is....
remember that Palpatine is already over 50 in TPM!

Yes and Obi-Wan in ANH looks about the same age as Palpatine in TPM so what's the problem?

so OB1 is old in ANH...

Yes. But he looks like a 50+ year old.

to be exact there is 32 years between TPM and ANH, taking that OB1 is 20 (I thought he was 22) that makes him 52, at least...

no, its his son, thus explaining how Owen is Luke's uncle.

ah! that's better... I think...

I agree with King Jedi - Obi-Wan does not look terribly old in ANH. I can believe he was only 55. Alec Guiness was about 62 when he made that film - thats not a huge difference.

don't remember what it was about...
I heared that there were 30 years and even 32 years between TPM and ANH, GL said that OB1 is around his 20s...

He's 25 in TPM..and his "state" might have a bit to do with his life as a hermit in Tatooine..it's not the easiest of lives.