Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

i was wondering what people thought was best. im going to buy one but dont know which one to get. third age for ps2 or battle for middle earth for pc.

i was looking at some reviews and it seems that battle for middle earth does seem to be the best.

sorry if this has already been said, i dont think it has.

Third age was a lot of fun, but it was so straight forward...and it was just a complete rip off of the movie.

I'd go for the battle for middle earth...it's got a lot of replay value and it's a lot of fun to play online.

Definitely Battle for Middle-Earth

Battle for Middle-Earth is definitely my favourite, having played on both games I rate B f M-E higher.

I've only played third age so I'd have to go with that one

dont get third age! that game is friggin FFX clone! plus theres the fact that there is no money whatsoever and you have to find weapons. its a terrible terrible game i tell you.

definetly Battle for middle earth!

BFME, though, it seems to me, that Gondor pwns all.