Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

We ALL know that Obi-Wan won in the Mustafar(Sp?) because of the enviroment. What if they fought, in a large empty room. No force power only lightsabers Who would win?

still Kenobi

if they fought in a large empty room it wouldnt be episode 3, therefore this would go in the versus forum.

please refer to this site for more info:

http://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/posting.php

id say Anakin

well obi wan only won cuz anakin got too cocky and jumped tryin to show off his *dark side of the force* powers. but i duno

Anakin would have destroyed Kenobi in a safe environment. Obi wan kept retreating from the fight until he could gain an adtvantage. Very smart indeed but without an advantage, Anakin wins.

Here is the problem I have with that fight. Anakin was clearly superior but not smarter. He developed what I like to call "sith overconfidence" ala maul.

obi wan