Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Battle's in the deserted and destroyed Jedi Temple.

Sidious would take him. He's just stronger than Bandon in all aspects of a duel. He also has more experience.

Bandon actually stands a good chance. He was the third most powerful person in Revan's Empire which included many Council Member Jedi Masters. Bandon has a great chance, actually, but Sidious does take him.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Bandon actually stands a good chance. He was the third most powerful person in Revan's Empire which included many Council Member Jedi Masters. Bandon has a great chance, actually, but Sidious does take him.

I agree. Bandon owns, and though he may appear weak for getting curbstomped by Revan - we must assume that Revan would be able to do just about the same thing to Sidious.

Why the heck would Revan even be able to touch Sidious who's the most powerful Sith of all time in the best time of the Sith? Bandon'd be wasted. Revan, too

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Why the heck would Revan even be able to touch Sidious who's the most powerful Sith of all time in the best time of the Sith? Bandon'd be wasted. Revan, too

Well, there are some articles that address and insinuate that Sidious was the most powerful of the Sith - and he was - at his own time. As much as I hate it, however, there are Sith Lords who can manipulate black holes, planets, ect. Sidious hasn't done anything on par with this, in terms of Force powers.

Read the EU on Sidious. You'd be amazed at the things he's done. Read my post in the other topic as well. 'ALL TIME' is not debateable and is directly stated no other Sith could compare to him.

At one point Sidious annihilates an entire fleet with nothing more than his rage, creating a force storm. That man's very existence unbalanced the Force

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Read the EU on Sidious. You'd be amazed at the things he's done. Read my post in the other topic as well. 'ALL TIME' is not debateable and is directly stated no other Sith could compare to him.

At one point Sidious annihilates an entire fleet with nothing more than his rage, creating a force storm. That man's very existence unbalanced the Force

That was Dark Empire Sidious. This isn't.

Bandon was a Dark Lord of the Sith during the Jedi Civil War, a three year battle against the Republic and its defenders, the Jedi Knights. He was second in line to Darth Malak, and arguably one of the deadliest Sith in the galaxy in that time of Jedi schism. His official profile says he's never been defeated (Except for Revan, but of course on that one.).

Contrast this with Sidious, who by the time of TPM was slightly above skill level of Darth Maul, and later on was disarmed by Mace Windu with a kick. Do you really see a war-time Sith Lord losing his lightsaber from a kick? Or is this where you become a movie fanboy?

I don't know whether to laugh or weep. Sidious, at the time of Episode 3? Well, as stated canonically was the mightiest of, what's that word.....oh, yes.....well, ever. SLIGHTLY above Maul? You really have no idea what you're talking about. And Mace is only on the top tier, probably the best duelist....y'know, that sorta thing.

Take it up with Leland Chee. Or the sourcebooks...or the books....or Marka Ragnos...or the EU. Either way, stop pretending you know a damn thing about Star Wars

Originally posted by Lightsnake
I don't know whether to laugh or weep. Sidious, at the time of Episode 3? Well, as stated canonically was the mightiest of, what's that word.....oh, yes.....well, ever. SLIGHTLY above Maul? You really have no idea what you're talking about. And Mace is only on the top tier, probably the best duelist....y'know, that sorta thing.

Take it up with Leland Chee. Or the sourcebooks...or the books....or Marka Ragnos...or the EU. Either way, stop pretending you know a damn thing about Star Wars

You're a ****ing moron. Stop using fanboy bias and hyperbole, please.

When you can deal with official sources, lemme know. Are flames your only response to this?

Originally posted by Blind Guardian
You're a ****ing moron. Stop using fanboy bias and hyperbole, please.

The funny thing is that he isn't. But you obviously haven't read anything related to Sidious, so you wouldn't know. What I find hilarious is that you whine about fanboy bias and hyperbole(of which there actually isn't any), when you can't post an actual argument against him.

You can't simply ignore certain EU if you're going to use other EU. Doesn't work.

Originally posted by Blind Guardian
That was Dark Empire Sidious. This isn't.

Bandon was a Dark Lord of the Sith during the Jedi Civil War, a three year battle against the Republic and its defenders, the Jedi Knights. He was second in line to Darth Malak, and arguably one of the deadliest Sith in the galaxy in that time of Jedi schism. His official profile says he's never been defeated (Except for Revan, but of course on that one.).

Contrast this with Sidious, who by the time of TPM was slightly above skill level of Darth Maul, and later on was disarmed by Mace Windu with a kick. Do you really see a war-time Sith Lord losing his lightsaber from a kick? Or is this where you become a movie fanboy?

Does that negate the possibility of it happening?

And we know Yoda can lift up X-wings....does it matter that he doesn't for ****s and giggles from time to time? we know Yoda can leap around like a crazed monkey...why doesn't he in ESB? We know Sidious can use a saber and leap around a room...why doesn't he when facing Luke?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Bandon actually stands a good chance. He was the third most powerful person in Revan's Empire which included many Council Member Jedi Masters. Bandon has a great chance, actually, but Sidious does take him.



Originally posted by Gideon
Well, there are some articles that address and insinuate that Sidious was the most powerful of the Sith - and he was - at his own time. As much as I hate it, however, there are Sith Lords who can manipulate black holes, planets, ect. Sidious hasn't done anything on par with this, in terms of Force powers.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_me2xajLWxl1qawxe1o1_500.gif

Why are you bumping such old threads?

Even back in 05 people thought this was a close fight?

What the ****?

The simple premise of this thread is hilarious, the content is ****ing gold.

Keep this an quality coming, Eliminist.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
The simple premise of this thread is hilarious, the content is ****ing gold.

Keep this an quality coming, Eliminist.

Agreed, lmao this is fvcking brilliant.


Certainly not Gid's finest moment... And Lightsnake really did change a forum.

He did indeed.

If anything, this is proof of Gideon's utter objectivity... Dude clearly had no allegiance to Sheev beyond what the evidence presented.

Lightsnake is prescient.

It would also be proof of Gideon's incompetence in regards to the act of debating back in '05.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
It would also be proof of Gideon's incompetence in regards to the act of debating back in '05.



Gideon's incompetence? Bit of an oxymoron, innit?

To be fair, I think he was like fourteen years old and pretty ridiculously eloquent for that age - but let's not let that get in the way of our mockery.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Gideon's incompetence? Bit of an oxymoron, innit?

lel, it amuses me how highly you think of yourself. It's always been so entertaining.

Well he must have found it so flattering when you bent the knee, apprentice.

Gideon's rhetoric did seem to change over the years. Were he around today, I'd imagine that he'd try to sound smug and Palpatine-like rather than produce robotic, sometimes awkwardly eloquent (?) walls of text.

Bandon has destroyed a table and was 3rd strongest of Revan's empire. Sidious isn't even a Dark Jedi compared to Revan's Sith Acolytes, and had trouble just hurling chairs.