Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who would win? Fight takes place outside on Cloud City. They can enter buildings to move to different landings and skywalks, but can only fight inside were Vader vs Luke pts 2 and 3 took place. Make sense?

Durge and Montross win, not because they are better skilled, but because their's Durge, nobody on the other team can kill him, Montross will also die, but Durge will be the only one alive at he end.

Greivous has a chance of putting Durge out of the fight, by jumping at him and putting his lightsabres on blender mode.

But Durge can heal himself and Durge is not going just stand there, while GG is doing that.

He'd probably try to fly away, and have Greivous jump up and slice him into 20 pieces. I think a knockout counts as a win.

No it doesn't, if Durge heals himself later and kills GG, that is no victory for GG.

Makashi's right that Grievous can't kill Durge but Jim is also right that Grievous can put Durge down temporarily, if a knock-out counts as a win then Grievous's team wins, if not then Durge's team wins.

Ok, if knock-out counts counts for a win i agree to , that GG would be victories, GG is more skilled then Durge and Jango is better then Montross, bit if its a fight to the death Durge wins.

Yeah, of course. Unless theire is a huge terrain advantage (such as a catapult to the sun nearby). But, Durge is reduced to goo, and every time he starts to reform, Jango shoots him a few times and Greivous chops him up. Then Jango and Greivous die of starvation, (or if in a terrain where ther is food, they die of old oage) and Durge comes back. However, I would hardly call that a "victory".

The other factor in here is Durge...

Durge can pull himself together pretty quickly.

Quicker than Greivous attacking at a speed of twenty strikes per second? I don't think so, especially seeing as how Greivous won't be needed in the fight against Montross.

But Durge is not going just to watch, while GG is attacking him, he can move and dodge and why would GG constantly attack Durge when he defeats him first, i think he would probably think he has already won, he was arrogant.

He can hit twenty times per second, he's one of the few people who could hit Durge. Also, Greivous was a brilliant strategist, and knew all about Durge, I doubt he would forget.

Yea i forgot and i know he is a brilliant strategist, probably the best in the universe at his time.

I dunno, Baby Thrawn could take him. How old was Ackbar?

I said at his time, not all time best.

Originally posted by jollyjim311
I dunno, Baby Thrawn could take him. How old was Ackbar?
Ackbar was born 44 bby so he was only like 22-25 years old during the Clone Wars. Dunno if he'd be betetr than Grievous was.

Oh well, that really doesn't matter right now. Point is, Greivous is fast enough to get the almighty Durge, and knows of his healing abilities, and won't give him the chance to fully recover.

GG was the best strategists, butt he had no chance of wining, Sidious controlled both sides.

So something I've always wondered, say GG cut his head off, it lies there and he sticks his lightsaber(s) in his brain and disintegrate it, can Durge come back from that if his brain is killed? Or if this were on Mustafar, would that be the same as when Anakin sent him for a little ride?

Geez!!! This is a tough fight. Not that it would be a bloody fight but a tough one to call. I guess GG and Jango win. Jango would probably have a close fight with Montross but kill him(as he did before) and if GG did go into "Blender Mode", he would be able to take down Durge long enough for Jango to shoot off a few wrist rockets into Durge's body. I mean, if you completely obliterate Durge so that most of his body is disintegrated, he wouldn't be able to fully re-heal, causing him a slow death. Overall, General Grievous and Jango Fett win.

GG and Jango are better skilled, but Durge is not gong just or stand there, while GG is blendering him, he would do something, like move away, or hit GG, his strokes are very powerful, it would hurt GG.

And what if Jango just hung out in the air shooting him with wrist rockets, his back rocket and blaster shots? he can heal that quickly?

And what would Monntross be doing at that time, just watching, Montross is like 90% of Jango, Jango defeated him with great difficulty. it would take some time to defeat Montoss.