Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Mace Windu(ROTS) vs Kyle Katarn(NJO)
Who wins?

I'm going for Kyle on this one.

I think Kyle may win.

You guys think that Anakin > Kyle (vader11) and not sure if Anakin could take Kyle or not (Riverollv) but you both think he could beat Mace? So you guys would put Anakin above Mace?


Anyways, not certain about this match, I'm actually leaning towards Mace, though his Vaapad won't help him against a Jedi like it would help him against a Sith.

Anakin in the zone may beat Mace

I'm actually thinking Mace in this one.

If this were Kyle before NJO, then I'd say Mace wipes the floor with him, since it isn't NJO Kyle isn't a match for Mace.

Originally posted by LORDSIDIOUS01
If this were Kyle before NJO, then I'd say Mace wipes the floor with him, since it isn't NJO Kyle isn't a match for Mace. It is NJO Kyle

DS, Anakin in the the "zone," despite how queer that sounds, could likely destroy almost anyone in saber combat.

Originally posted by vader11
It is NJO Kyle


My mistake. NJO Kyle beats Mace

If he does, it will be with a high amount of difficulty.

Originally posted by Gideon
If he does, it will be with a high amount of difficulty. I agree. Kyle would win in a close fight.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
DS, Anakin in the the "zone," despite how queer that sounds, could likely destroy almost anyone in saber combat.
Not NJO Luke and up, maybe not DE Luke, not DE Sidious, possible not Kyle, Bane w/ armor, Tulak Hord. No, not everybody.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Not NJO Luke and up, maybe not DE Luke, not DE Sidious, possible not Kyle, Bane w/ armor, Tulak Hord. No, not everybody. So Kyle is likely to beat Mace.

Kyle goes down here, just because i hate him so much.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
DS, Anakin in the the "zone," despite how queer that sounds, could likely destroy almost anyone in saber combat.

Actually there are quite a few people still above him including but not limited toL

Luke
Jacen
Corran
Kyle
Yoda
Sidious
Exar
Ulic
Nyax

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Kyle goes down here, just because i hate him so much. You are LORDSIDIOUS01 the second

Kyle wins in a close fight

Originally posted by darthsith19
Not NJO Luke and up, maybe not DE Luke, not DE Sidious, possible not Kyle, Bane w/ armor, Tulak Hord. No, not everybody. That's why I said "likely" and "almost."

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Actually there are quite a few people still above him including but not limited toL

Luke
Jacen
Corran
Kyle
Yoda
Sidious
Exar
Ulic
Nyax
Kyle, Yoda, Sidious, Exar are all subject to debate, some of which have already been done. Anakin has a fair chance at beating any of them in saber combat (no force powers). But even still, you named what, nine people? What percent is that of every lightsaber wielding fighter in SW?

Com on, he defeats Exar, Ulic, Sidious for sure, i think he defeats Yoda to, Kyle is debatable also and who is Nyax?

This is kind of hard to judge, since Mace is from before Kyle was born, and they have two completely different styles of combat. I think though, that Kyle may win since he has more experience fighting different Dark Jedi, and many with different styles.

I think Kyle at his peak is even more uber than Mace in saber.