Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Qui-gon Jin vs. Count dooku.
Place: cloud city
Who would win? Both are at their peak performance.

Dooku

Dooku. Easily.

Dooku

There is simply nothing Qui-Gon can do to dooku. He's better then him in every way.

Except in hair.

Or becoming one with the Force.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Except in hair.

True

Dooku stomp



Wait, Qui-gon also beats Dooku in he "getting impaled" portion of the talent show!

Dooku via pwnage.

I mean come on, the dude was 80 and still beat AOTC Anakin and Obi-Wan 2 on 1.

count dooku as dooku was as good as yoda during the clone wars.

Originally posted by Oppo Rancisis
count dooku as dooku was as good as yoda during the clone wars.

When you say "dooku was as good as yoda" you really meant to say that Dooku was inferior to Yoda, right?

right. obviously.

Dookie.

Doku. Super Sith Doku.

Dooku crushes him. He is far superior in force and saber skills.

For F***s sake Dooku TRAINED Qui-Gon

Originally posted by Pwned
For F***s sake Dooku TRAINED Qui-Gon

Doesn`t mean much. Students often get better than their masters. Anakin would have far surpassed Obiwan or even Sidious. Exar Kun killed his master etc etc.

True, but in the case of the jedi, it typically doesnt happen alot, especially when the Master is very powerful then the student typically doesnt become more powerful

Originally posted by Pwned
True, but in the case of the jedi, it typically doesnt happen alot, especially when the Master is very powerful then the student typically doesnt become more powerful

You can flip that around too because most Jedi who grow very powerful studied under a powerful master. Naturally the top masters will pick the students with the most potential.

Anyway percentages does not apply here since we are talking about specific individuals rather than mr x and y.

It might be that Qui-gon would've been able to beat Dooku when Dooku was as young as him, or if Qui-gon had lived to Dooku's age he might've been able to meet and surpass him. But that didn't happen and is speculation anyway, so Dooku's peak is clearly higher than Qui-gon's.

Originally posted by Mshinu
You can flip that around too because most Jedi who grow very powerful studied under a powerful master. Naturally the top masters will pick the students with the most potential.


Anyway percentages does not apply here since we are talking about specific individuals rather than mr x and y.

Yes, very true.

Originally posted by Q99
It might be that Qui-gon would've been able to beat Dooku when Dooku was as young as him, or if Qui-gon had lived to Dooku's age he might've been able to meet and surpass him. But that didn't happen and is speculation anyway, so Dooku's peak is clearly higher than Qui-gon's.


Yep.

I wonder if Quigon`s "living in the moment" philosophy weakened his fighting ability, but also enabled him to return from the netherworld.

Hmmmm...qui-gon jin is a powerful jedi. He's intelligent and has great wisdom but Dooku Was an ex-jedi with the same training and some trainging from a sith lord... Dooku would win this fight.