Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Battle takes place on Yavin IV in a Forest.

Who takes this?

1. Sabers

2. Force

3. Hand-to-Hand

4. Blasters

5. Vibroblades

6. All-Out

I'm not sure it would be a stomp either way, but I feel inclined to favor TSL Meetra. Revan-novel Meetra just seems like an elite mook, which is a tragedy of the highest order.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
I'm not sure it would be a stomp either way, but I feel inclined to favor TSL Meetra. Revan-novel Meetra just seems like an elite mook, which is a tragedy of the highest order. I know it's unfortunate, but we do all know Karpyshyn's book is Canon, and I don't recall it ever saying Meetra was weaker in the book then in TSL, though any sane person would assume that, seeing as Meetra is a powerhouse in it.

Meetra is comparable to Revan practically in TSL, having ridiculous charisma, Force leech ability, the ability to affect her allies in the Force, potential battle precog, etc. etc.

Meetra in the book demonstrates none of this and she's barely noticable. Drew's book may be canon, but it's shit-canon.

Malak would probably dominate this. It wouldn't be an easy fight, but there's really no question to who'd be the victor in my perspective.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Meetra is comparable to Revan practically in TSL, having ridiculous charisma, Force leech ability, the ability to affect her allies in the Force, potential battle precog, etc. etc.

Meetra in the book demonstrates none of this and she's barely noticable. Drew's book may be canon, but it's shit-canon. Point is, it's Canon, even in the book, it tells very briefly of when Meetra defeated Traya, we can't argue TSL vs Karpyshyn's book "Revan." While I wish Meetra was comparable to Revan, she isn't, and it sucks, because Karpyshyn ruined all the power she had. :/

Drew just decided to not honor the ideas of KotOR II because he didn't have any involvement and it was made by Obsidian, not Bioware. Honestly, TSL Revan is probably better than Drew's Revan as well.

No, he just didn't bother to play the game or research it properly.

Agreed about TSL Revan. Now that guy was interesting.

Yeah, SW's answer to Caesar or Hannibal.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Meetra is comparable to Revan practically in TSL, having ridiculous charisma, Force leech ability, the ability to affect her allies in the Force, potential battle precog, etc. etc.

Meetra in the book demonstrates none of this and she's barely noticable. Drew's book may be canon, but it's shit-canon.

The Exile deserves better.