can Rey take on Luke

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



SWblayde938
Rey at the end of TFA could she beat the Luke she found?

ares834
lol

no

EmperorSidious2
No way

FreshestSlice
Originally posted by ares834
lol

no

SWblayde938
but since the EU is non-canon anymore

how powerful is Luke in TFA?

Q99
She could beat, like, ANH Luke. Start-of-ESB Luke.

Originally posted by SWblayde938

how powerful is Luke in TFA?

Unknown, but he's a fully trained Jedi.

FreshestSlice
She probably can't even take on start of ESB Luke given his newer canon feats.

As to this thread, Luke is literally the most powerful warrior in the galaxy currently. What the **** is Rey supposed to do but die? If she could defeat Luke there would be no point in finding him. I mean I guess she could cry or something, and he'd feel bad enough for him to leave an opening, but that's about it.

Dark-Kenshin
Luke effortlessly rag dolls this mary-sue character called Rey, though I bet Disney will do something silly like make her the most powerful character in the mythos eventually.

GenomeFrozener
Originally posted by Dark-Kenshin
Luke effortlessly rag dolls this mary-sue character called Rey, though I bet Disney will do something silly like make her the most powerful character in the mythos eventually.

You don't like force sensitives who can train themselves?

Dark-Kenshin
Originally posted by GenomeFrozener
You don't like force sensitives who can train themselves? Nah, I just don't like mary sues.

Q99
^^;; Rey is not a Mary Sue.


Originally posted by FreshestSlice
She probably can't even take on start of ESB Luke given his newer canon feats.

What new canon feats does he have?

She has some staff fighting experience going in.

FreshestSlice
Yeah, and Luke has saber training and experience as well as a few Force showings by the start of ESB now. I don't see Rey taking on multiple magnaguards as long as Luke did, and this was before saber training.

Q99
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Yeah, and Luke has saber training and experience as well as a few Force showings by the start of ESB now. I don't see Rey taking on multiple magnaguards as long as Luke did, and this was before saber training.

He took on Magnaguards? This I did not know.

Which thing was that in?

NTJack0
Originally posted by Q99
He took on Magnaguards? This I did not know.

Which thing was that in? The comics, sport.

Tzeentch
By canon, yes*. With Legends, no.

*I actually have no idea what Luke's canon feats are.

Rebel95
She would get destroyed lol. I'm sure she'll be pretty powerful by the end of this new trilogy though

Q99
Originally posted by NTJack0
The comics, sport.


Specifically, which thing? There's multiple comics with Luke.

The Ellimist
up

darthbane77
The shit I took this morning is more threatening than Rey is tbh.

Kurk
The only Luke is taking out is ANH.

That being said, don't underestimate the power of the femi-nazis

The Ellimist
^ Darth Sidious is extremely powerful; does this mean his fans are all white supremacists? erm

Ziggystardust
Yes

Darth Thor
Originally posted by ares834
lol

no

Dread Dark
*bump*

Jmanghan
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Yeah, and Luke has saber training and experience as well as a few Force showings by the start of ESB now. I don't see Rey taking on multiple magnaguards as long as Luke did, and this was before saber training. ...In the start of ESB, Luke was having significant trouble trying to bring a lightsaber to his hand.

Its actually ****ing... crazy that they are trying to give him force feats before ESB.

TenebrousWay
I'm sure she will. She will defeat the greatest force user ever and then be defeated by some random dude in IX, who will become the new greatest ever.

That's Star Wars at it's finest.

The Ellimist
Originally posted by Jmanghan
...In the start of ESB, Luke was having significant trouble trying to bring a lightsaber to his hand.

Its actually ****ing... crazy that they are trying to give him force feats before ESB.

Luke at that point is likely erratic in his Force ability; he wasn't confident enough to use his lightsaber until he faced Vader, but then he does well enough to land a hit in and for Vader to say he's the most powerful Jedi he's ever faced. In RotJ he struggles against a rancor and some random scout troopers but then holds the upper hand over Vader.

Zenwolf
Originally posted by Kurk
The only Luke is taking out is ANH.

That being said, don't underestimate the power of the femi-nazis

Eh I dunno, just give Luke a blaster and he could do it.

Zenwolf
Originally posted by Jmanghan
...In the start of ESB, Luke was having significant trouble trying to bring a lightsaber to his hand.

Its actually ****ing... crazy that they are trying to give him force feats before ESB.

Yeah cause it's not like Luke just hadn't been mauled by a Wampa and hung upside down for an unknown period of time with the blood rushing to his head.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.