Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Classic Puck (before gaining superstrength and durability) v. Captain America in unarmed combat (i.e. no shield)...

who wins?

Very close, almost exact stats in every area. I may give Cap the slight and I meany slight majority (6/10)

Even with enchanced skills Puck would have a hard time, I know he is old and experienced but Cap is a h2h beast, he wins the mayority here.

Originally posted by Bentley
Even with enchanced skills Puck would have a hard time, I know he is old and experienced but Cap is a h2h beast, he wins the mayority here.

What? I don't think you know what Puck is capable of if it's upgraded version Puck wins 10/10. Also Puck is a h2h beast as well.

I don't know if Puck has been upgraded lately, but Cap punked Spidey after the power boost he got in the Other, so while Punk still wins Cap would put a fight.

Cap wins. That's what his character does.

Besides, you know, dying.

Originally posted by Bentley
I don't know if Puck has been upgraded lately, but Cap punked Spidey after the power boost he got in the Other, so while Punk still wins Cap would put a fight.

He was upgraded in the 90's, he's invulnerable and indestructable there is nothing Cap could do to Puck. Plus Puck has Spider-Man speed and strength as well as reflexes, and 100 years of experience.

Originally posted by Bentley
Besides, you know, dying. This is like his second time dying. He'll be back.

If he can be knacked down its still a win. The Spidey the Cap beat h2h was faster and stronger than classic Spidey and Cap punked him at least twice. The experience is why I think will win this fight for Puck. But for the record, Cap is very good at what he does. Pre upgrade I don't see Puck winning.

Originally posted by Bentley
If he can be knacked down its still a win. The Spidey the Cap beat h2h was faster and stronger than classic Spidey and Cap punked him at least twice. The experience is why I think will win this fight for Puck. But for the record, Cap is very good at what he does. Pre upgrade I don't see Puck winning.

No it isn't, as Puck is vastly more durable than SPider-Man. Experience? Puck has basically the exact same experience as Cap even fighting in the same battles. Technically he has been doing this longer as Cap was frozen for so many years while Puck continued fighting. I suggest you check out the Puck respect thread as pre upgrade Puck was a beast even took it to Savage Hulk.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
I suggest you check out the Puck respect thread as pre upgrade Puck was a beast even took it to Savage Hulk.

Didn't AuntMay stop SavageHulk once?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Didn't AuntMay stop SavageHulk once?

She's beaten everyone, and even became a hearld for Galactus as "Golden Oldie"...and yes I'm serious.

If Puck can ditch more damage than the Cap can cause I see him winning, if you can put a durability scan here it would be appreciated (it would make Puck more noticeable here since people respect him less than I do)

Originally posted by King_Mungi
She's beaten everyone, and even became a hearld for Galactus as "Golden Oldie"...and yes I'm serious.

I've seen the GoldenOldie scan.

But I remember someone talking about her stopping SavageHulk with a frying pan or something

I agree that upgraded Puck (after his DNA was altered by The Master) would prolly win hands down...Classic Puck, on the other hand, makes it a very close fight...

Originally posted by Bentley
If Puck can ditch more damage than the Cap can cause I see him winning, if you can put a durability scan here it would be appreciated (it would make Puck more noticeable here since people respect him less than I do)

1. http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e54/A_Flight6/AlphaFlight100-03.jpg

Actually Puck since the respect thread he has been greatly respected on this board

Puck Respect Thread: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/423912_1-alpha-flight-puck-respect-thread

puck is a beast, but in h2h skill he not as skilled as capt.

He isn't, but no way is he far below.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
He isn't, but no way is he far below.


No one said puck was far below.




Hell puck likly a top tier fighter, but he just not as skilled as capt.

Indeed, that's why I gave Cap the slight majority as Puck can win but Cap will win the majority.

Captain America versus Classic Puck goes to Steve. Often.

Captain America versus upgraded Puck (minus his enhanced durability) is a draw-ish.

Captain America versus upgraded Puck (period) goes to Puck 10/10.