Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Rank Rate and order

Offense with gear
Offense h2h
Overall formidability

Candidates.

Nightwing
Elektra
Batgirl
Shiva
Daredevil
Batman
Black Panther
Taskmaster
Grren arrow Ollie
Hawkeye Clint

Offense with gear
Offense h2h
Overall formidability

Candidates.

Batman 10
Nightwing 9
Daredevil 9
Grren arrow Ollie 9
Elektra 8
Batgirl 7
Black Panther 6
Shiva 6
Taskmaster 6
Hawkeye Clint 6

I took their experience (at least what i know about it) into account. Streetwise.

10 = Knows the streets like no other and how to deal with the scum (the big and the small).
5 = Average, Boys in the hood
1 = Barbiegirl in her barbieworld

Nightwing - 8
Elektra - 9
Batgirl - 7
Shiva -6
Daredevil - 9
Batman - 10
Black Panther - 10
Taskmaster - 10
Grren arrow Ollie - 6
Hawkeye Clint - 6

Are we going by current ronin Clint or Clint when he was hawkeye

Nightwing - 8
Elektra - 7.6
Batgirl - 7.3
Shiva - 9
Daredevil - 8
Batman - 9.8
Black Panther -9.9
Taskmaster - 10
Grren arrow Ollie - 6
Hawkeye Clint - 6
Captain America - 10

Originally posted by BattleMage
Nightwing - 8
Elektra - 7.6
Batgirl - 7.3
Shiva - 9
Daredevil - 8
Batman - 9.8
Black Panther -9.9
Taskmaster - 10
Grren arrow Ollie - 6
Hawkeye Clint - 6
Captain America - 10
You seriously believe Cap would beat Batman when it comes to cleaning up the streets of a city?

He's not even one of the choices

Originally posted by Omega Vision
You seriously believe Cap would beat Batman when it comes to cleaning up the streets of a city? Well tell me who's on the street's that bats can handle that cap can't?

Originally posted by BattleMage
Well tell me who's on the street's that bats can handle that cap can't?
Clayface, Joker, Poison Ivy, Riddler. And that's just Gotham. Cap is as good a fighter but he lacks Batman's intelligence and gadgetry. It takes more than just kickass moves to stop the more insidious, powerful, and clever criminals and villains. Not to mention when it comes to the streets a red white and blue costume is like a big bullseye. To say Cap would be a good candidate to clean up a city is folly, he's better off fighting Hydra.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Clayface, Joker, Poison Ivy, Riddler. And that's just Gotham. Cap is as good a fighter but he lacks Batman's intelligence and gadgetry. It takes more than just kickass moves to stop the more insidious, powerful, and clever criminals and villains. Not to mention when it comes to the streets a red white and blue costume is like a big bullseye. To say Cap would be a good candidate to clean up a city is folly, he's better off fighting Hydra. He would already have a file on these guy's so he would do as good a job or better than bats!

Originally posted by BattleMage
He would already have a file on these guy's so he would do as good a job or better than bats!
A file? No sir. Nothing can prepare a person for Joker except experience, he has no protection against Poison Ivy, he wouldn't be smart enough to get through Riddlers traps, and he doesn't carry anything that could put down Clayface. He doesn't have Batman's awesome gear or experience and he's not well suited to be an urban crime stopper. Batman is better as an urban Avenger that's a fact.

Offense with gear

Nightwing- 6
Elektra- 9
Batgirl- 4
Shiva- 7
Daredevil- 7
Batman- 10
Black Panther- 10

Offense h2h

Nightwing- 6
Elektra- 10
Batgirl- 10
Shiva- 9
Daredevil- 8
Batman- 8
Black Panther- 7


Overall formidability

Nightwing- 6
Elektra- 9.5
Batgirl- 7
Shiva- 8
Daredevil- 7.5
Batman- 9
Black Panther- 8.5

Originally posted by Omega Vision
A file? No sir. Nothing can prepare a person for Joker except experience, he has no protection against Poison Ivy, he wouldn't be smart enough to get through Riddlers traps, and he doesn't carry anything that could put down Clayface. He doesn't have Batman's awesome gear or experience and he's not well suited to be an urban crime stopper. Batman is better as an urban Avenger that's a fact. Your right about the Joker but, Cap still kills bats enemys. (Joker included)

Originally posted by BattleMage
Your right about the Joker but, Cap still kills bats enemys. (Joker included)
How does he beat Ivy or Clayface? And do you really think he's Batman's equal in stealth, interrogation, and intelligence? Do you really think he's as good at remembering every nook and cranny of a city?

Originally posted by Omega Vision
How does he beat Ivy or Clayface? And do you really think he's Batman's equal in stealth, interrogation, and intelligence? Do you really think he's as good at remembering every nook and cranny of a city? Cap is a bad mofo. So whatch out.

Originally posted by BattleMage
Cap is a bad mofo. So whatch out.
So is Batman. Difference is that Batman is a bad mofo with years of experience on the streets, one of the world's greatest brains, and an arsenal of gadgets designed to defeat virtually any threat that comes his way.
I agree that Cap stalemates or beats Batman in hand to hand combat but in every other area (except leadership) Batman edges him out. Batman is way more versatile.

From high 10 to low.

Offense with gear
6 Nightwing
2 Elektra
4 Batgirl
3 Shiva
4 Daredevil
10 Batman
9 Black Panther
8 Taskmaster
5 Grren arrow Ollie
7 Hawkeye Clint

Offense h2h
6 Nightwing
4 Elektra
10 Batgirl
8 Shiva
4 Daredevil
9 Batman
5 Black Panther
7 Taskmaster
3 Grren arrow Ollie
2 Hawkeye Clint

Overall formidability
8 Nightwing
4 Elektra
7 Batgirl
6 Shiva
5 Daredevil
9 Batman
10 Black Panther
8 Taskmaster
2 Green arrow Ollie
3 Hawkeye Clint

^That's a screwed up list.

Originally posted by vansonbee
From high 10 to low.

Offense h2h

6 Nightwing

4 Elektra

5 Black Panther



so much effort put into your list, how do you get it so wrong?

Elektra is probably THE single greatest human - non enhanced - Ninja on the planet. And Nightwing is at best the very low end of top 10 human - non enhanced - MA's on DC earth.

Originally posted by Juk3n
so much effort put into your list, how do you get it so wrong?

Elektra is probably THE single greatest human - non enhanced - Ninja on the planet. And Nightwing is at best the very low end of top 10 human - non enhanced - MA's on DC earth.
Not to mention that by his own scoring of Black Panther it makes no sense for him to be a ten overall.

Offense with gear
Hawkeye
Black Panther
Taskmaster
Batman
Ollie
Batgirl
Elektra
Nightwing
Shiva
Daredevil

Hawkeye has nukes. Nuff sed.

Offense h2h
BlackPanther
Taskmaster
Batgirl
Shiva
Batman
Elektra
Daredevil
Nightwing
Ollie
Clint


Overall formidability
Black Panther
Taskmaster
Hawkeye
Batman
Shiva
Elektra
Ollie
Batgirl
Nightwing
Daredevil